Tampa Bay Outdoors

printer version

Rating sand, sea and surf

By Times staff
© St. Petersburg Times
published June 21, 2002

Welcome to our special section on beaches. Our cover headline, This Is The Life, perfectly describes what this section is about. After all, if you live in Tampa Bay, some of the most beautiful beaches in the world are right outside your door.

In addition to our lead story, we highlighted five beaches with specific allure. Fort De Soto is perfect for families. Clearwater Beach is one big party. Caladesi Island is a nature-lover's dream. Anclote Key is great for boaters. And Pass-a-Grille is a sunset paradise.

To tie our five stories together, we sent several of our staffers to each beach and came up with a 10-category ratings system. We also rated the other beaches that fall between Anclote Key to the north and Fort De Soto to the south.

Our original plan was to spend hundreds of hours on our critiques, but then we got . . . distracted. We went armed with pen and paper. But it was hot. And the water looked great. And there was that smell of grilling hamburgers . . . And all those drinks with the little umbrellas . . .

Okay, so we lost track. That tends to happen at a beautiful beach.

In the end, we came up with the following good-natured ratings system. If you disagree with any of our findings, don't get too upset. It's all in fun.

Here are the 10 categories. (Keep in mind that the weather was perfect on the day we did our ratings.)


1) Sand quality: Is it white, fluffy, rocky? Is there plenty of it?


2) Food: Are restaurants, snack shops, convenience stores and ice cream parlors plentiful and accessible?


3) Restrooms: Are there plenty of them? Are they clean? Safe?


4) Parking: Are there lots of spots? Parking meters?


5) Access: How bad is the traffic flow getting to the beach? How many traffic lights, drawbridges, etc.?


6) Aesthetic appeal: When you stand with your back to the water, what do you see?


7) Water quality: Is it clear? Good flow? Any dangerous currents?


8) Safety: Are there lifeguards, police patrols? Is there a lot of boat traffic? Are there stingrays or sharks?


9) Shade: Are there any trees? Can you rent cabanas or umbrellas?

photo 10) Activities: Volleyball, jet skis, entertainment centers?

The best rating is five starfish . The poorest is one1 starfish.

Back to Beaches
  • Desired Effect
  • Romp in the Park
  • Beauty and the Beach
  • Rating sand, sea and surf
  • Join the Fun
  • Air Dynamics
  • Swingers
  • Beach rentals
  • Island Sea-clusion
  • A Smashing Success
  • Imagination on Display
  • Beauty Lying Around
  • Beach bummin'
  • Surf shop fashion sense
  • Common Hazards
  • outleftnav
    fishing report
    tide charts
    Terry Tomalin
    Dorian Cushing
    [an error occurred while processing this directive]

    Back to Top

    © 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
    490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111