St. Petersburg Times Online: News of Florida
Place an Ad Calendars Classified Forums Sports Weather
  • Delays in death row case irk governor
  • Judge overturns verdict against gun distributor
  • Super Bowl XXXVII: Only Floridians saw pitch on glories of state's citrus
  • Churches may push mentoring
  • 1 killed in plane crash; 3 missing
  • More than 800 doctors skip work to decry insurance rates
  • Senators hand in budgetary wish lists
  • Around the state: Teen's trial in fatal beating will be moved to Pinellas
  • Board accepts Bush's intervention
  • Ex-police officer in Jacksonville gets life in slaying

  • From the state wire

  • Hurricane Jeanne appears on track to hit Florida's east coast
  • Rumor mill working overtime after Florida hurricanes
  • Developments associated with Hurricanes Ivan and Jeanne
  • Four killed in Panhandle plane crash were on Ivan charity mission
  • Hurricane Frances caused estimated $4.4 billion in insured damage
  • Disabled want more handicapped-accessible voting machines
  • USF forces administrators to resign over test score changes
  • Man's death at Universal Studios ruled accidental
  • State child welfare workers in Miami fail to do background checks
  • Hurricane Jeanne heads toward southeast U.S. coast
  • Hurricane Jeanne spurs more anxiety for storm-weary Floridians
  • Mistrial declared in case where teen was target of racial "joke"
  • Panhandle utility wants sewer plant moved to higher ground
  • State employee arrested on theft, bribery charges
  • Homestead house fire kills four children, one adult
  • Pierson leader tries to cut off relief to local fern cutters
  • Florida's high court rules Terri's law unconstitutional
  • Jacksonville students punished for putting stripper pole in dorm
  • FEMA handling nearly 600,000 applications for help
  • Man who killed wife, niece, self also killed mother in 1971
  • Producer sues city over lead ball fired by Miami police
  • Tourism suffers across Florida after pummeling by hurricanes
  • Key dates in the life of Terri Schiavo
  • An excerpt from the unanimous ruling in the Schiavo case
  • Four confirmed dead after small plane crash in Panhandle
  • Correction: Disney-Cruise Line story

    printer version

    Judge overturns verdict against gun distributor

    A circuit judge says the decision in the case centered around Nathaniel Brazill's weapon was inconsistent.

    ©Associated Press
    January 28, 2003

    WEST PALM BEACH -- A judge threw out a $1.2-million verdict Monday against the company that distributed the gun 13-year-old Nathaniel Brazill used to kill a teacher 21/2 years ago.

    Circuit Judge Jorge Labarga ruled that the Nov. 14 award to Lake Worth Middle School teacher Barry Grunow's widow, Pam Grunow, was inconsistent because the jury also determined that the gun was not defective.

    The award was the first issued against the firearms industry because of the absence of a gun lock and the overall design of a cheap, easily concealable weapon known as a "Saturday night special." Gun safety advocates said the verdict would force the industry to make safer guns.

    Pam Grunow sued gun distributor Valor Corp. after her husband was gunned down in a school hallway in May 2000. She claimed Valor should have made the gun safer by installing a lock or other device.

    The verdict had largely spared Valor itself from blame in the closely watched case.

    The six-woman jury found that Valor was only liable for 5 percent of a $24-million judgment for selling the small handgun Brazill used.

    Valor attorney John Renzulli said Labarga's ruling shows the gun industry can't be held liable in such cases. He said the blame belonged with Brazill and with Elmore McCray, who owned the .25-caliber Raven handgun and stored it in a drawer, unlocked and loaded, where Brazill found it.

    Brazill, now 16, was sentenced to 28 years in prison. He said he pointed the handgun at his favorite teacher to scare him and never intended to pull the trigger.

    "We know what happened here; a criminal got in touch with a gun and shot somebody in cold blood," Renzulli said. "That's certainly not Valor's fault."

    Grunow's attorneys said Valor was notified thousands of times by federal officials that products it distributed were used in crimes, but the company did nothing to make the weapons safer. They also argued that the gun is unreliable and isn't used by collectors, law officers or the military, or for target practice, hunting or self-defense.

    Sunrise-based Valor Corp., with 14,000 licensed firearms dealers nationwide, argued in the case that the gun did what it was designed to do and wasn't at fault.

    The original verdict assigned half of the blame to McCray, and another 45 percent to the Palm Beach County School Board for allowing Brazill to bring the weapon, hidden in his pocket, onto campus. McCray and the school were never expected to pay the verdict because they weren't defendants in the suit.

    The jury decided that Pam Grunow deserved $10-million for her loss and her children, 7-year-old Samuel and 3-year-old Lee-Anne, each deserved $7-million.

    Rebecca Larson, Grunow's attorney, said Pam Grunow was disappointed in the judge's ruling Monday, particularly after an emotional six-week trial. She said the ruling will be appealed.

    "Pam's feeling, her primary objective has always been to make a difference," Larson said. "She knew from the beginning that this was not going to be easy."

    Larson said the company's actions should be considered negligent even though the jury determined the gun was not defective.

    "For example, take a medication that's perfectly legitimate and not a defective product. If you sell it in a bottle that doesn't have a tamper-proof cap, you're negligent," Larson said.

    Brazill stole the gun from McCray after being sent home the last day of school for throwing water balloons. He returned to the school to say goodbye to two girls and became angry when Grunow wouldn't let him inside his classroom.

    Back to State news
    Back to Top

    © 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
    490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111
    Special Links
    Lucy Morgan

    From the Times state desk