St. Petersburg Times
Online: Tech Times
 tampabay.com
Print storySubscribe to the Times

Opinion

Rant, Rave

By PETE YOUNG
Published September 7, 2003

Simmons case shows NCAA still has no clue

Willie Simmons waited through three seasons to become the starting quarterback at Clemson last fall. However, by the end of the season, he was on the bench.

Simmons did not win back the starting job in the spring, so he transferred to Florida A&M, near his hometown of Quincy, for his final season of eligibility. FAMU is a Division I-AA school, so Simmons immediately was eligible and was projected to be the starting quarterback.

After Simmons transferred to FAMU, the school announced plans to move to I-A next season. His final year of eligibility was safe - until some blockheads at the NCAA decided it wasn't. Simmons was declared ineligible at FAMU because it intended to become a I-A school, even though it was, a) I-AA when he transferred and, b) would be I-AA when he played.

Simmons, who has graduated, transferred again last month, to The Citadel, another I-AA school. He started the opener, guiding the Bulldogs to an easy win. Hopefully, it works out for him, but sadly, such stupid rulings are common.

This week, Arkansas star offensive lineman Shawn Andrews had his eligibility restored. While at a photo shoot of preseason All-Americans in May, he took two T-shirts from a gift bag left in his hotel room. Andrews had to make reparations of $20.50.

Once again, the NCAA has lived up to its alternate acronym: No Clue, As Always.

ESPN analysts Alberts, May are perfect together

Michael Irvin has added a blast of charisma to ESPN's NFL coverage, and Chris Fowler, Lee Corso and Kirk Herbstreit deserve their status as the premier sources of all that is college football.

But the best pigskin analysis and interaction this fall is coming from ESPN college studio analysts Trev Alberts and Mark May.

Rarely are former sports stars - May was an All-American at Pitt, Alberts an All-American at Nebraska - as good in their second careers as their first, but these two pull it off famously.

Alberts and May are informed and insightful, and they play off of each other.

Alberts, once a fiery linebacker, is the more passionate. May, an offensive lineman who had a stellar pro career (Alberts, a first-round pick, had his cut short by injury), is more even-keeled. But May doesn't back down, and Alberts' bravado usually is supported by facts and reason.

They love to disagree, and their cogent debates are entertaining, but they're not afraid to agree, unlike other similarly paired analysts. ESPN NFL analysts John Clayton and Sean Salisbury are highly informed but sometimes seem more interested in being combative.

May and Alberts have a breadth of knowledge and opinions that span Division I-A football, and they deliver it with style.

[Last modified September 7, 2003, 02:02:02]


Baseball

  • M's DH deserves star's farewell
  • AL: Halladay goes 10 to blank Detroit
  • Bosox rout makes history
  • NL: Simon provides juice and meat
  • Report: daughter okayed decapitation

  • College football
  • Mi-OH-Mi!
  • Bulls make a stand to stave off an upset
  • FSU continues its re-emergence
  • Brown wants respect from OSU
  • State: Dougherty finds comfort zone to lead FAMU
  • Beard breaks through for UM
  • No-huddle attack fires up Berlin, offense
  • Florida-Miami still draws the big money
  • UF gameballs
  • Offense suddenly rounds into shape
  • USF by the numbers
  • USF gameballs
  • WR Hicks finally finds college end zone
  • Nation: Munson's big day lifts Broncos
  • Sooners fend off Tide
  • Former area standout shines for Terps
  • FSU by the numbers
  • FSU gameballs
  • Jones rings up points instead of opponents

  • Colleges
  • UF by the numbers

  • Conferences
  • SEC: Risk pays off for Gamecocks
  • Big East: After star goes down, Hokies wake up, cruise
  • Big Ten: In '02 flashback, Buckeyes hold on
  • C-USA: TCU sluggish but good enough to win
  • Big 12: Colorado again scores late to win
  • Pac-10: Irish rebound for OT victory
  • ACC: Tech sends Auburn to second loss

  • Golf
  • 5-6 Tanaka hoping for a big finish

  • Gotta minute?
  • Aubrey Huff

  • In brief
  • Long shot surprises top fillies in Gazelle

  • Motorsports
  • Hearn's lap sets record, earns pole
  • Newman wins again as hot tempers flare

  • NFL
  • Coles expresses bitterness at FSU
  • Jets ground Blackwell
  • Make you go, hmmmm ...
  • TV, football lace tight partnership

  • Opinion
  • Rant, Rave

  • Outdoors
  • Daily fishing report
  • Preparation counts for archery season

  • Preps
  • 'Cats bring Barons back to earth
  • Pirates extend dominance of Rams
  • Replacement ends Leopards' chance

  • Tennis
  • Henin-Hardenne gets 2nd Slam
  • Capriati keeps her chin up after loss
  • Roddick wakes up in time
  • Letters: Your Turn
  • Rays
  • Rays get 'moral victory' with rare real one against the A's
  • LaForest impresses in catching debut
  • Lou's past can't ease distress
  • Bucs
  • Defining Moments: Joe Jurevicius
  • Best of the Bucs
  • Defining Moments: Ronde Barber
  • Deja vu? Bucs now believers
  • Lightning
  • A little competition doesn't hurt
  • Ten questions
  •  


    Back to Top

    © 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
    490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111