St. Petersburg Times
Online: Tech Times
Print storySubscribe to the Times


Rant, Rave

Published December 7, 2003

When is a catch not a catch?

The spectacular, diving, full-extension catch has gone the way of the dodo bird. It is extinct.

The NFL killed it.

Exhibit A: Ronde Barber's oh-my-God-what-a-grab interception late in the Bucs' loss to the Jaguars Sunday. It was awe-inspiring. It was physics-defying. It was, possibly, game-changing.

It was even more impressive on replay. Barber launched himself, stretched his arms out of their sockets to get a fingertip on Byron Leftwich's pass, seized it while fully outstretched and sailed several feet before crashing to the field.

The ball, upon impact with the ground, moved a smidgen as Barber drew his arms in to clutch it to his chest. The official watched this mind-boggling feat on replay and ... overruled the initial call. No catch.

Excuse me? Barber had the ball locked between his hands for the flight back to earth, the ball never came close to releasing from his hands and the ground in no way assisted him. But it is not a catch because the ball moved a few millimeters after he had established control?

That, in a word, is absurd-crazy-dumb-insane-moronic-stupid.

Memo to the NFL: If the ground doesn't assist the catch, then it is a catch. Barber and others are being robbed by ludicrous rules.

Running rings around the greed

Mark Richt has done wonders at Georgia, going 31-7 in three seasons. He immediately took the Bulldogs, mired in mediocrity since Herschel Walker departed, to the proverbial next level. He sustained it this season despite a glut of injuries.

The SEC East champions played Saturday for the conference title against West Division champ LSU. Georgia aimed for back-to-back titles and another SEC championship ring.

Last season nine Bulldogs sold that ring. Valued at about $350, the nine fetched about $1,500-$2,000 apiece. It's hard to blame them - that's a lot of cash to a college student - but impossible not to.

This isn't about how revenue-generating college athletes get short-shrifted financially, because they do. It's about the rings, which were free and represent the hard work of every player and coach on the team, not just the individual receiving it. They represent something intangible and invaluable, an achievement to be cherished forever, not cash for a new set of speakers or video games.

Georgia hadn't won an SEC crown in 20 years, yet several players sold off the symbol of that accomplishment. Richt was appalled, and last week he announced that if Georgia won again, the nine would have to buy their own rings.

Good move. We hope it will deliver the proper message, not merely cut into their profit margin.

[Last modified December 7, 2003, 01:34:09]


  • Agent says MLB is lying about revenues

  • College basketball
  • 'Noles' rout doesn't impress their coach
  • 3's propel Charlotte to a double-OT victory
  • Homely victory likely to move Gators to No. 1
  • Huskers show off power, beat Bulls
  • Late slump doomstop-ranked Kansas
  • Arizona averts upset by inches
  • Sooners edge Spartans in OT
  • Different Gators defeat Seminoles
  • Spartans overwhelm a pesky Kent State

  • College football
  • Oklahoma loses - now what?
  • USC states its BCS case
  • KSU shocks unbeaten Sooners
  • LSU dominates from start, defeats Georgia
  • Miami expects three stars to leave early
  • Navy win has Army at 0-13
  • Syracuse ends skid as Irish finish another losing season
  • USC states its BCS case

  • Golf
  • Furyk mightiest of major champs

  • In brief
  • Klitschko becomes WBC top contender

  • Motorsports
  • CART teams wait for resolution of issues

  • NBA
  • Chicago may shed flat pair
  • Mavs extend Magic's woes

  • NFL
  • Dolphins land in snowstorm
  • For Stecker, hate mail hits home
  • NFL picks
  • The bottomline
  • Things that make you go hmmm ...

  • NHL
  • Hull ties for third in goals; Detroit loses
  • Slapshots

  • Opinion
  • Rant, Rave

  • Outdoors
  • Daily fishing report

  • Parimutuels
  • Derby Lane ready for early opening

  • Preps
  • Armwood reaches 4A final with blowout win
  • Cook leads Venice at tourney
  • Countryside defends its tournament title
  • QB tandem roughs up East
  • Riverview wins tourney with three class winners
  • Whalen fighting off cancer
  • Letters to the Editor: Clijsters represents the best of sports
  • Rays
  • Perez bolsters Rays bench
  • Rays focus on 3 outfielders
  • Bucs
  • Futility Lines
  • A 5-7 predicament tests heart
  • Bucs-Saints matchup
  • Kickin' back with Darian Barnes
  • Sideline
  • Letters to the Editor: Let QBs on bench test their mettle
  • Lightning
  • Captain and team on track
  • Obscenities don't faze Sunshine

    Back to Top

    © 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
    490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111