St. Petersburg Times
Tampa Bay Lightning
Print storySubscribe to the Times

The puck stopped here

A replay of an apparent goal by Calgary is ruled inconclusive by officials.

Published June 6, 2004

[Times photo: Dirk Shadd]
Martin St. Louis scores the game-winning goal 33 seconds into the second overtime period to square the series at 3-3 and set up Monday's showdown at the St. Pete Times Forum.
Main story
Gary Shelton: Series going the distance is not unexpected
John Romano: St. Louis wins it, but Richards saves season
Photo gallery
At the Forum, a (blue) hue and cry
Bradleys at home in Tampa
Goalie comparison
Nancy converts (a couple of) her neighbors
No guarantee, just a grind
Richards' first goal good for the omens
Sound bites
St. Louis saves his best for the end
Taylor's role is as a fiery leader
Three stars
The puck stopped here
Click on each score for the main story from each game
(Lightning wins series 4-3)
Tuesday [5/25]: Calgary 4, Tampa Bay 1
Thursday [5/27]: Tampa Bay 4, Calgary 1
Saturday [5/29]: Calgary 3, Tampa Bay 0
Monday [5/31]: Tampa Bay 1, Calgary 0

CALGARY - Craig Conroy calls Martin Gelinas "the Eliminator."

And Gelinas almost eliminated the Lightning Saturday night in Game 6 of the Stanley Cup final.

Gelinas, who owns the NHL record with three series-ending overtime goals, almost had the Cup clincher on his skate blade with about seven minutes left in the third period, but a video review by NHL director of hockey operations Colin Campbell concluded that Nikolai Khabibulin stopped the puck short of the goal line, denying Gelinas the biggest goal of his career.

The sequence started on a Calgary breakout when forward Oleg Saprykin knifed in on Khabibulin from the right and attempted to center to Gelinas, who was crashing the goal.

Khabibulin sprung from the crease to obstruct the pass, which bounced against Gelinas' right skate and toward the goal line. Because Gelinas was not making a kicking motion when the puck struck his blade, it would have counted had it crossed the line. The puck struck Khabibulin's right pad where it bends over the skate, however, and video replays showed how close it came to crossing the line, though no direct overhead shot was available.

After Khabibulin's stop, play continued as fans in the Saddledome groaned at the missed scoring chance.

"We thought we had the big play," Flames coach Darryl Sutter said.

NHL spokesman Frank Brown said the play was reviewed from multiple angles, but because the angle that showed the puck was from high over Khabibulin's shoulder, and because the puck was on edge and in the air, there was not enough evidence to rule it a goal.

As with all goal decisions in the playoffs, the final judgment was made by Campbell in Toronto. Campbell said during an intermission interview with the CBC that replays were inconclusive and a goal could not be awarded.

Though the nongoal was a source of controversy within the Canadian media, the Flames had not had time to see the replay or chose not to address it after the game.

Sutter said the replays he saw convinced him it was not a goal.

"No, I looked at it, and that's got to be a conclusive play," Sutter said.

"I looked at it at two different angles, and to make that call it has to be conclusive."

Gelinas said he was not aware there was a controversy until asked about it after the game.

"They would have called us back if it was a goal," Gelinas said. "He made the save.

"They have so many cameras they would have called down if it went in."

But what if they got it wrong? What if there were insufficient camera angles.

"That would be pretty tough," Gelinas said. "It would be pretty tough, with just a few minutes left. Shame on them if that's the case."

Lightning forward Tim Taylor didn't think it was a goal to begin with, and saw another problem with the play.

"I thought it was directed in by a skate," Taylor said. "He was going right toward the net and stopping on it. So that wouldn't have been a goal."

Either way, the Eliminator was denied.

- Information from the Associated Press was used in this report.

[Last modified June 6, 2004, 01:31:04]

Today's lineup

  • At the Forum, a (blue) hue and cry
  • Bradleys at home in Tampa
  • Goalie comparison
  • Nancy converts (a couple of) her neighbors
  • No guarantee, just a grind
  • Richards' first goal good for the omens
  • Slapshots
  • Sound bites
  • St. Louis saves his best for the end
  • Taylor's role is as a fiery leader
  • Three stars
  • One last shot
  • The puck stopped here

  • Rays
  • A pitcher or position player? Rays draft not cut and dried
  • Who will the Rays take?
  • Devil Rays look for ways to solve tough division
  • Martinez's return a swinging success
  • Got a minute, Rey Sanchez?
  • Rays tales
  • Rays to let Bonds get his swings

  • Other sports

    Arena League
  • Storm falls short in bid for repeat

  • Baseball
  • Jesuit ace is back on track
  • AL: Rangers rookie nabs memorable first win
  • NL: Myers slams door for Phillies
  • Top draft picks remain unknown
  • Not much expected from draft

  • Colleges
  • FSU one game from advancing
  • Gators hold off UCLA to reach region final

  • Golf
  • Els seizes lead with big, easy 66

  • Gymnastics
  • Texan dominates U.S. juniors - again

  • In brief
  • Capel wins in the 100 in Oregon

  • Little League
  • Northeast wins with a no-hitter

  • Motorsports
  • Hunter-Reay wins a Champ Car rout
  • Mayfield likes his view from the front of field

  • NBA
  • In Motown and in Hollywood, coaches' theme is 'Respect'

  • NFL
  • Testaverde is finally just one of the 'Boys

  • Opinion
  • Rant: Hockey just won't be the same

  • Outdoors
  • Daily fishing report
  • Rules no help so far at Boca Grande Pass

  • Preps
  • Farragut coach happy with the rapid progress
  • Burroughs beats rain, opponents in Orlando
  • Memorable occasion

  • Tennis
  • Argentina wins today either way
  • Myskina beats buddy in sloppy final

  • The Belmont
  • Outsmarted
  • A record Belmont crowd for Smarty Jones

  • Your turn
  • Letters to the Editor: Champions should be admirable, not abhorrent
  • Back to Top

    © 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
    490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111