St. Petersburg Times
Online: Tech Times
Print storySubscribe to the Times


Stop the chop? Broncos called out

Published October 31, 2004

A below-the-knee block by Broncos right tackle George Foster on defensive tackle Tony Williams during the Bengals' 23-10 win Monday night has created a brouhaha across the NFL.

The Bengals believe Foster's block, which dislocated and fractured Williams' left ankle and ended his season, was unnecessary and another example of the Broncos' unsavory blocking methods.

Jaguars defensive end Paul Spicer was lost earlier this season with a broken leg after being blocked by Broncos left tackle Matt Lepsis. The league determined Lepsis' block, like Foster's, was legal.

"I've been talking about it for 10 years," an annoyed Broncos coach Mike Shanahan said at a news conference last week. "It's one of those situations where the average football fan really doesn't understand that all teams do that. All teams do it. In the game, Cincinnati had a number of them."

At his news conference last week, Bill Cowher was asked what he thought of the block. The Steelers coach said it was uncalled for and warned the Broncos to "do unto others as you want them do onto you."

Shanahan was "a little offended" by Cowher's remarks and invited members of the Denver media into the film room. He took particular care to show footage of Steelers guard Alan Faneca cutting down Raiders tackle Ted Washington on opening weekend.

There is a gray area between the legal cut block and the illegal chop block. The cut block occurs when a player (usually an offensive lineman) blocks another (usually a defensive lineman) below the knees with his helmet in front of the player. The chop block occurs when the same block comes from the side or the back, or when the defensive player is engaged with another offensive player and therefore defenseless.

Many suggest the league outlaw the cut block and eliminate the potential for the chop block, which can cost up to $20,000 in fines.

"It's unfortunate, and I'm sure it's something the competition committee will look at," Bengals coach Marvin Lewis said. "From what I understand, this is the second player that was injured against the Denver Broncos on blocks supposedly legal, but not really needed, not necessary."

Offensive linemen argue that the difference between the legal and illegal block is difficult to gauge.

"The only difference between the chop block and the cut block is where you have your head," Bucs center John Wade said. "Ahead or on the side of him, it's a matter of inches."

The problem is some teams, like the Broncos, have a long-standing reputation for being particularly adept at the below-the-knee block. In just the past four seasons, five players have been severely hurt by a similar block while playing against the Broncos.

Interestingly, Denver has traditionally had one of the best running games in the NFL and is at it again, ranked second in the league at 147.6 yards per game.

"The left tackle for the Broncos (Lepsis) has to be about 280 pounds and he's really quick," Bucs defensive end Greg Spires said. "That's his main thing, it's to cut. He's the best at it. He does it the legal way, but sometimes (the illegal way) happens and when it does, he should be punished."

As long as legs and ankles continue to be broken, the cut block likely will be revisited by the league in the offseason, and there appears a growing sentiment against it.

"I've been in the league 27 years now, and from the first year to this year I've never taught a block below the waist," Redskins veteran offensive line coach Joe Bugel said. "I think the integrity of the game is, if you're an offensive lineman, you block above the waist, you block on your numbers, you block on the hips - but you don't block anybody's knees."

Information from other news organizations was used in the report.

[Last modified October 31, 2004, 00:57:29]


  • Subplots plentiful in Bosox's tale
  • Red Sox fans let it all out after an 86-year buildup

  • College football
  • ACC: Wake Forest finally pulls out a close one
  • Big East: Troublemaking receiver propels Mountaineers
  • Big Ten: Michigan wins in triple OT
  • C-USA: East Carolina denies Army 3rd straight win
  • Nation: UTEP's fifth straight win seals rarity
  • PAC-10: USC romps to 17th straight win
  • State: Florida Atlantic offense has record-setting day
  • Big-12: Sooners barely remain unbeaten
  • SEC: Vols all but wrap up East

  • Commentary
  • Rant: Happy Red Sox fans? That just feels wrong

  • Florida Gators
  • Game balls
  • Dog day afternoon
  • By the numbers
  • Dawgs celebrate long-awaited win against Gators
  • Georgia bites Bailey again
  • Faith, family help Zook endure

  • FSU Seminoles
  • Terrapinned!
  • No bailout from defense this time
  • QB controversy? Give Bowden few minutes

  • Golf
  • Singh poised for history
  • Golden ties Park for 1st with eagle
  • Veteran in surprising battle

  • In brief
  • Tiebreaks lift Agassi to final

  • Motorsports
  • NASCAR loses its teacher
  • J. Burton to stay at RCR in 2005
  • Kenseth is double trouble for challengers

  • NFL
  • NFL picks: week 8
  • Point/Counterpoint: The cut block
  • Roll call
  • Steelers say Patriots' manhandling continues
  • Stop the chop? Broncos called out

  • Outdoors
  • BASS move brings acclaim to Florida
  • Daily fishing report

  • Parimutuels
  • Ghostzapper exorcises Classic winless streak

  • Preps
  • Calvary has banner victory
  • Clash a prep for playoffs
  • Friday night rewind: Pinellas
  • Gaither star Quick fights off bad week to make state meet
  • Hurricanes sweep boys, girls titles
  • Knights' Justus wins region diving
  • Largo meets coach's hopes
  • Masterson back on top at region
  • Sickness can't slow Pirate
  • Tigers take the A-3 title

  • Pro basketball
  • News worse for Pacers star, now out 6-8 weeks

  • Pro hockey
  • Veterans have to stop this madness

  • Sports in print
  • Times writer takes first place in Florida Press Club contest

  • Sunday Extra
  • Ali's Rumble helped shape black culture

  • UM Hurricanes
  • Kicked out

  • Your turn
  • Letters to the Editor: Zook's firing tactless
  • Bucs
  • Griese showing pedigree
  • Return of Galloway will provide a boost
  • Letters to the Editor: It's only fair that Brown catches heat

    Back to Top

    © 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
    490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111