St. Petersburg Times
Online: Tech Times
 tampabay.com
Print storySubscribe to the Times

Commentary

Faceoff

Should the Superdome be torn down?

By Times staff writers
Published September 18, 2005

NEW ORLEANS SHOULD PUT A LID ON PAINFUL MEMORIES AND GET RID OF DOME

In time, the floodwaters will recede. In time, people will return to their homes. In time, New Orleans will be rebuilt.

When it is, the last thing residents will want is a monolithic reminder of everything that went wrong in the wake of the worst natural disaster in American history.

People will not look at the Superdome and recall fond memories of concerts, Super Bowls, even a pope's visit.

They will remember the starvation, looting, rape and murder that took place in and around its walls after Hurricane Katrina.

Builders can decontaminate, deodorize and dry out the dome. Restore power, repair holes and lay new carpet. But they'll never fully cleanse the building of the devastation and heartbreak it has come to symbolize.

Consider, too, the effect on the city's psyche if the Saints move to San Antonio or Los Angeles, leaving the building empty without a full-time tenant.

Tear down the dome, which is past the point of repair, and focus instead on finding displaced residents homes and jobs.

- FRANK PASTOR

DON'T TEAR IT DOWN; HISTORY WAS MADE THERE AND IT WILL BE MADE AGAIN

The message from President Bush on down about New Orleans is clear: The city must be rebuilt.

As people trickle back to New Orleans, homes and businesses should be first on the rebuilding list. The rebuilding of a sports stadium should only be addressed after more important needs are satisfied.

But when the issue of the Louisiana Superdome does come up, here's hoping New Orleans decides to fix up the landmark stadium instead of tearing it down. The stadium has stood since 1975, when the Saints played their first NFL season in the dome. Since then it has hosted six Super Bowls, four NCAA Final Fours and every Sugar Bowl, as well as numerous other events.

Yes, the Superdome was a horrible place during Hurricane Katrina. Yes, it received extensive damage, especially to the roof. But rebuilding the dome would be a nod to New Orleans' resilience. Like the city, the Superdome is wounded but not dead. Certainly not this year, maybe not next year, but down the road the Superdome should rise again as a symbol of the strength of those in New Orleans.

- RODNEY PAGE

[Last modified September 18, 2005, 02:15:36]


Baseball

  • Tigers' heads are everywhere but in the game
  • 1969 World Series MVP Clendenon dies at 70
  • AL: Sox slump: stymied by Santana
  • Boston's Ramirez does it again
  • NL: Marlins bad news in ninth

  • College football
  • Big 10: Michigan unloads on EMU
  • Big 12: Huskers block winning field goal
  • ND can't solve MSU
  • PAC-10: UCLA capitalizes on Sooners' bumbling
  • 'Canes offense starts to jell
  • ACC: Emergency QB sparks W. Virginia
  • Big East: QB's elusiveness gives Virginia a late victory
  • Not much special in Wyoming victory
  • Rattlers give their new coach his first victory
  • SEC: Vandy holds off Ole Miss, gets to 3-0

  • Colleges: FSU 28, BC 17
  • Weatherford takes command
  • B.C. a Davis family favorite
  • Game balls

  • Colleges: UF 16, UT 7
  • Ironic revenge
  • Junior kicker makes good impression
  • Gators lose key receiver, lineman to injury

  • Colleges: USF 31, UCF 14
  • Hall shows the door to UCF in Bulls' win
  • Timely instant replay goes the Bulls' way
  • Bulls' defense grows up to the task
  • Game balls

  • Commentary
  • Faceoff
  • The Buzz

  • Golf
  • Gore up by 2 over party of 5

  • In brief
  • Boxer in surgery with head trauma

  • Martial arts
  • Life filled with focus and fight

  • Motorsports
  • Momentum intangible needed in the Chase
  • Gordon, Earnhardt steal the spotlight
  • Pit box holds much more than tools of the trade

  • NFL
  • Brodeur not handling rule well
  • On the sideline
  • Today's games
  • Saints player helps with engagement

  • Outdoors
  • Put down the video game, pick up a rod

  • Preps
  • Bounced coaches, bouncing back
  • CCC stops Sickles
  • Crystal River falls short of title
  • Gator outdistances the field
  • Home course favors Brandon
  • No home cooking for 'Canes
  • Pinellas football roundup
  • Vikings hire ex-Eckerd player

  • Sunday Extra
  • Young & bold
  • The young Americans

  • Tennis
  • Kickin' back: He's still Ilie after all these years
  • France, Russia tied 1-1 in Fed Cup final
  • Letters to the Editor: Respect for Bulls
  • Rays
  • Brazelton's 'nightmare'
  • Crawford hits his mark
  • Got a minute? Carl Crawford
  • Hollins: Just let it happen, be ready
  • Miscommunications hounding Rays
  • Bucs
  • Bucs' offense overpower Bills
  • Lest you forgot about him
  • Williams, Bucs real competitors
  • Cadillac ready to carry workload
  • Bucs ready for home spark
  • Lightning
  • Duo will alternate in goal during preseason
  • Evolution of a new superstar
  •  


    Back to Top

    © 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
    490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111