Print

Email story

Comment

Email editor

Disagreement mars Mideast democracy summit

MANAMA, Bahrain - A U.S.-backed summit meant to promote political freedom and economic change in the Middle East ended Saturday without agreement, a blow to President Bush's goals for the troubled region.

A draft declaration on democratic and economic principle was shelved after Egypt insisted on language that would have given Arab governments greater control over which democracy groups receive money from a new fund.

U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice also used the conference to send a message to Syrians chafing under authoritarian rule, saying Washington backs their "aspirations for liberty, democracy and justice under the rule of law."

Bush hosted a coming-out party for the Forum for the Future last year at Sea Island, Ga., and the United States is putting up half of the $100-million in a venture capital fund for economic development launched at this year's gathering.

The White House had hoped the conference would showcase political progress in a part of the world long dominated by monarchies and single-party rule, and spread goodwill for the United States.

American officials seemed startled that an ally, Egypt, threw up a roadblock.

Egypt receives nearly $2-billion annually in U.S. aid, second only to Israel. The country held its first multiparty elections this year, but remains under the firm control of President Hosni Mubarak.

The disappointing outcome at the conference followed a rocky summit a week ago in Argentina.

In Bahrain, tense negotiations in private over the language of a final statement could not persuade the Egyptians.

Bahrain's foreign minister, Sheik Khalid bin Ahmed Al Khalifa, told reporters the declaration will come up again, perhaps at a gathering in Jordan next year.

"We don't want to issue a haphazard decision," Khalifa said. "We decided we will come back to it one day."

Many Middle East nations are wary of Bush's second-term democracy agenda for the region. Some organizations that the administration has tried to engage are reluctant to take money from the United States.

"It would be a disaster for this region if the region thought democracy is an American idea," British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw said at the closing news conference, where the final agreement had been expected to be released.

"America is a great country, but democracy was born in Greece, just across the Mediterranean," from the Middle East, Straw said.

As intended, the 36-nation session launched a $100-million venture capital fund to promote economic enterprise. The fund includes $50-million from the United States, with contributions from Egypt, Morocco and Denmark.

The conference also started a $50-million foundation aimed at promoting democracy and political change in the Middle East.

Both initiatives were shepherded by U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary of State Liz Cheney, the vice president's daughter. She accompanied Rice on a Mideast trip to Bahrain, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Israel and the West Bank.

U.S. officials said the sticking point was a passage in the declaration that pledged "to expand democratic practices, to enlarge participation in political and public life and to foster the roles of civil society," including nongovernmental organizations, and to widen women's political and economic participation.

Egypt wanted the statement to stipulate that those organizations, known as NGOs, be "legally registered" under each country's laws. U.S. officials said the requirement would undermine the purpose of the statement.

[Last modified November 13, 2005, 03:00:43]