Americans in air pollution hot spots worry that it's causing their children to suffer from poor health and impaired development. But little research exists.
By Associated Press
Published December 18, 2005
Dick Wittberg knows that each year factories rain hundreds of thousands of pounds of manganese dust over his hometown of Marietta, Ohio. He also knows that manganese is a heavy metal that can harm the brain and nervous system.
What worries Wittberg, a biologist who heads the mid-Ohio Valley Health Department, is what he doesn't know and can't find out: How all that toxic pollution is affecting the lives and health of children in his community.
Wittberg has been pressing for a full-blown government study of the manganese pollution's health impact since he took part in a pilot study in the late 1990s that compared Marietta children to those in a similar-sized Ohio town on academic and physical tests. The Marietta kids fared significantly worse.
"We didn't do anything that in any respect proves that this is manganese that has done this, because there are other scenarios that are entirely possible," he said. "But in my opinion, it really points to some environmental problem that is causing some neurological differences, and one has to suspect manganese. Nobody knows for kids how much is too much."
Similar concerns span the country, though communities with the worst factory pollution sometimes are frustrated they don't have more research to rely on.
In the Detroit suburb of Ecorse, which has sued U.S. Steel after enduring decades of air pollution, Mayor Larry Salisbury wants the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to investigate how industrial toxins affect health.
"We think there have been citizens who had an early death because of health issues related to that steel plant," Salisbury said. "It would be great if the CDC would study certain towns to make the case."
"Sometimes I think the government doesn't want to know the answers," he said. "Once they do, they have a certain liability to enforce."
U.S. Steel spokesman John Armstrong said his company took over the Ecorse plant in 2003 from bankrupt National Steel and has spent millions cleaning up problems. "We take great pride in our environmental stewardship and are addressing these issues as quickly as possible," he said.
An Associated Press analysis of federal pollution, health and census data found that more than 30 neighborhoods around the Great Steel Works plant in Ecorse rank among the worst 5 percent nationally for potential health risks from industrial air pollution.
The AP used health risk scores calculated by the Environmental Protection Agency. The measures can be used to compare the chronic health risk from industrial air pollution from one part of the country to another.
The study found that eight states - Ohio, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Indiana, Texas, Michigan, Wisconsin and Missouri - account for almost half the total health risk nationally from factory air. Nearly one-tenth of the total risk is concentrated in Ohio, especially along the heavily industrialized Ohio River corridor.
Farther east, Camden, N.J., has more than 100 contaminated industrial sites and seven minority neighborhoods that rank among the top 1 percent in the nation for the long-term health risk from factory pollution.
Dr. Robert Pedowitz said his Camden practice sees about 25 patients a day for asthma or allergy complaints, more than any other private practice in New Jersey. One of the main triggers, he said, is air pollution.
"It severely affects the quality of life," Pedowitz said. "It makes people tired, affects their ability to function."
In the Ohio River Valley where Wittberg lives, nine neighborhoods in and around Marietta and Wood County, W.Va., rank among the worst 100 nationally for health risks from factory emissions.
There are more than 20 industrial plants along or near the Ohio River in those two counties. The plants regularly spew tens of thousands of pounds of manganese, chromium, sulfuric acid and formaldehyde.
"It's a toxic soup of contaminants because of all the different facilities in the area," said Michelle Colledge, an environmental health scientist with the federal Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry.
The river corridor also is a major contributor to factory air pollution in West Virginia, which has the highest health risk per person of any state. Indiana ranks second in per capita health risk, followed by Ohio, Pennsylvania, Iowa and Alabama.
Residents around Marietta, with the help of Sen. Mike DeWine, R-Ohio, petitioned the government several years ago to study the health impact of the region's air.
Tina Trombley, president of Recover, a local environmental group, said the community wanted to find out for sure if the high incidence of asthma and several types of cancer are the result of air pollution.
The study found arsenic and manganese in the air consistently exceeded levels that scientists believe could harm health, but provided no definitive link to disease. Further monitoring at specific sites was ordered.
"We need to do a full-fledged study and we're hoping that's what they will be able to do for us," Trombley said.
The initial federal study focused on an industrial complex south of Marietta that includes four major facilities. The largest, the Eramet Marietta metal refinery, released more than 550,000 pounds of manganese compounds in 2000, and more than 25,000 pounds of chromium compounds. Another facility, Eveready Battery, releases more than 16,000 pounds of manganese compounds a year.
Jeff McKinney, environmental manager at Eramet, said neither the study nor any other data suggest that "emissions from area industry have adversely impacted the health of residents. Moreover, we have not seen manganese exposure-related neurological effects in our long term employees."
For Colledge and Wittberg, the area offers a unique opportunity to determine conclusively how long-term exposure to manganese dust affects humans, particularly children.
The pilot study Wittberg participated in several years ago included an EPA researcher and a University of Quebec scientist. They measured differences between children in Marietta and those in Athens, a similar-sized Ohio town 45 miles away.
They gave a battery of 13 tests to fourth-graders in both cities, who had been matched for age, sex and parental education. The tests measured such things as educational proficiency, balance, visual contrast sensitivity and short-term memory.
"The Marietta kids did worse on almost everything," Wittberg said.
The implications are potentially far-reaching if the Marietta children's IQ scores turn out to be 10 to 15 points lower because of manganese exposure, he said.
"Brilliant kids are now simply smart; smart kids are average and average kids are not average any more," Wittberg said. "I believe it is the whole lives of the kids that are affected. I don't think that the damage can be undone."