You make the call

Tonight's the night to cast your final vote. Who will be the next American Idol?

By SHARON FINK and SEAN DALY
Published May 23, 2006

---

KATHARINE MCPHEE

Age: 21

Residence: Los Angeles, Calif.

Catchphrase: Catch McPheever!

Loyal Fanbase: Anyone who has paid to see Celine Dion; foot fetishists

Fashion: Pre-Raphaelite meets Forever 21

Best Performance: Somewhere Over the Rainbow in the final three

Worst Performance: That Hound Dog/All Shook Up debacle for Elvis Week

Best Simon Snark: After the Elvis mess, "It looked like a desperate, manic audition."

It Factor: Great voice, great hair, great curves

Ick Factor: McPhakeness

Ten Years From Now: Playing Belle in Beauty and the Beast . . . in Des Moines, Iowa.

TAYLOR HICKS

Age: 29

Residence: Birmingham, Ala.

Catchphrase: Soul Patrol!

Loyal Fanbase: That guy who sold you nails at Home Depot; that guy's wife

Fashion: Soccer dad chic.

Best Performance: You Are So Beautiful for the final three

Worst Performance: Take Me Home, Country Roads for Country Week.

Best Simon Snark: After Stevie Wonder's Living for the City, "Your appeal is that you're like every dad who ever got drunk at a wedding."

It Factor: Makes Home Depot guy think that he can sing, too.

Ick Factor: Dude, you're not Ray Charles . . . or Joe Cocker . . . or Michael McDonald.

Ten Years From Now: Auditioning for the lead in The Sam Cooke Story.

AND THE WINNER IS . . . TAYLOR HICKS