St. Petersburg Times
Special report
Video report
Multimedia report
Print Email this storyEmail story Comment Email editor
Fill out this form to email this article to a friend
Your name Your email
Friend's name Friend's email
Your message
 

Special report: The homeless struggle

Police slash open tents to roust the homeless

By ABHI RAGHUNATHAN and ALISA ULFERTS
Published January 20, 2007


photo
A man who identified himself only as Tommy, left, and Ken Argo hang around a campsite on 15th Street in St. Petersburg on Friday after police officers destroyed many of the tents or took them altogether.

  • Video of the raid Note: video contains sensitive language.
  • [Times photo: Lara Cerri]
    ADVERTISEMENT

    ST. PETERSBURG - City officials raided two homeless camps Friday afternoon, seizing more than 20 tents and further rattling a community still shaken from the slayings of two of its own.

    Those who refused to get out of their tents or remove their belongings watched as two dozen police and fire officials sliced the tops of the tents away from their bases, tossed them into a truck and drove off. Some said they didn't have enough time to get out before the officials began to cut with scissors, box cutters and other blades.

    "I was in the tent when they started cutting," said Ken Argo, 54, who said he was asleep when police arrived. "It was very reckless of them."

    The whole operation took less than 10 minutes.

    The raid was the city's latest attempt to deal with the highly visible tent camps that have sprung up in recent weeks and a homeless population that is becoming increasingly organized and close-knit. Last week the city shut down a tent city on Fourth Avenue N after it said it helped about 100 of its residents get social services, including rent vouchers and bus tickets to cities where relatives or friends could help.

    Those who didn't get or refused services soon set up their tents at one of two locations, Fifth Avenue N at 15th Street or Fifth Avenue N at Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street.

    But fire officials soon observed a host of fire code violations at the two satellite tent cities, said Lt. Rick Feinberg, a spokesman for the Fire and Rescue Department. People were smoking and cooking in their tents, he said. The tents were too close together, too close to public thoroughfares, and they didn't have fire extinguishers, he said.

    Feinberg said the homeless also failed to get the required permits for their tents, which were set up on the public right of way.

    "They were all in violation of codes," Feinberg said. "No one submitted plans for preparations for these two tent cities."

    It's not clear if all the fire codes the city cited indeed apply. The code requiring a permit specifies tents greater than 120 square feet, which is larger than the tents used by most of the homeless. And a state fire statute initially cited by the city doesn't deal with tents, said a spokeswoman for the state fire marshal.

    Still, city officials said their job is to protect and that there were significant safety concerns at the two locations, including danger from heavy traffic. City officials also said the homeless were given the chance to remove their belongings from the tents and were offered mats at a nearby shelter.

    Rather than arrest or get in physical altercations with those who refused, the officers cut the tents, said Deputy Mayor Dave Metz.

    "The tents were retained for evidence," Metz said.

    The city's action outraged the homeless community, which said that instead of taking away tents, the police officers should have been searching for the people who killed two homeless men early Wednesday.

    "And now they're putting all these people in jeopardy again," said Rev. Bruce Wright of Refuge Ministries. The reason the homeless cluster in tents is for safety, Wright said.

    Metz acknowledged the criticism but said the city did what it had to do. "I think you always have those implications, but our primary concern was safety."

    Wright said that advocates for the homeless, who met Friday with the city to discuss things like getting fire extinguishers, plan to sue the city over the destruction of the tents and will seek an injunction to prevent another raid.

    "We're getting more tents," Wright said.

    "We're bringing down the big guns now. We're gonna sue 'em."

    Abhi Raghunathan can be reached at araghunathan@sptimes.com or 727 893-8472. Alisa Ulferts can be reached at ulferts@sptimes.com or (727) 892-2379.

    [Last modified February 8, 2007, 11:17:09]


    Share your thoughts on this story

    Comments on this article
    by August 12/10/07 12:41 PM
    That's it mats on the floor and 24/7 religion shoved down their throats. Sick, very sick.
    by Nate 04/24/07 06:41 PM
    Why don't all of you who say this is a horrible thing post your address for those homeless people to move into your front yards? Yeah, maybe it could have been dealt with in a different manner but, it's time to get the homeless out of the city.
    by Cassie 03/02/07 09:37 AM
    The tents are all the people have...and we took that away from them too. We are horrible people!
    by Lois 02/28/07 05:17 PM
    To all of you who have offered food & supplies to the homeless and left feeling good about themselves I say: Support the homeless, Take one home with you. I don't need them deficating in my yard, throwing beer bottles & trash for us to pick up.
    by SPANDY 01/28/07 08:13 AM
    Instead of spending $400,000 on a study for a bicycle path across the Courtney Campbell for a handful of bike riders, take this large amount and help the homeless people instead. There always seems to be plenty of money to spend on stupid projects!!!
    by Fred 01/24/07 07:39 PM
    I have the solution for the homeless & the starving for the State of Florida & when we get all the bugs worked out. It will work all over the world. And it can be done at no cost to the tax payer. TOP-NOTCH-SECURITY
    by John 01/22/07 07:43 PM
    Perhaps there are indeed reasons that you might not want tent cities of homeless folks cropping up any-old-where in your city, but there has to be a better way to deal with it than this. I wonder how many civil rights were violated in this raid
    by Manuel 01/22/07 02:34 PM
    Housing both the homeless and the lowest income earners in the US may finally become an issue that will be addressed. The problem is so bad that the police have no other option than Gastopo tactics. Even some FLA civil servants are homeless.
    by John 01/22/07 02:10 PM
    Those who wanted help got it, those who were declined were so as they are able to get jobs. Maybe the homeless should take the hint - put the crack pipe down and get a job. I don't work 60 hours a week to support YOU!
    by Matthew 01/22/07 02:08 PM
    If they have free use of showers and some clothing at temp shelters than they need to get to work, find their feet and get to work. If they chose not to use these services provided from a variety of outlets, then they need to be removed. Good job SP
    by Pam 01/22/07 02:01 PM
    I think we should quit spending so much money on the criminals in prison and give some of it to the homeless. the saying is you can't judge someone until you have walked a mile in their shoes.We need to take care of our law abiding citizens.
    by Chris 01/22/07 01:58 PM
    Using drugs or alcohol kicks you out of the homeless help programs. They choose these things over shelter and work. Why should I pay for their lack of personal responibilty? No one is paying my bills except me.
    by Joe 01/22/07 01:57 PM
    Imagine if the police dept and the Mayor were this aggressive in going after the drug dealers and murderers. The homeless are an easy target. The real criminals are much tougher. We could use this amount of policing in Barlett & Childs Park.
    by Eliz 01/22/07 01:56 PM
    This is not only a homeless problem. I am outraged that our city Police Department would cut up the personal possessions of these people. Where is the outrage for the loss of their civil rights. I hope they sue the city and sue it hard.
    by Cheri 01/22/07 01:36 PM
    I think this is disgusting what the city has done. Taking the tents away is akin to someone breaking into someone's house and commiting a robbery. SHAME on the city officials that concocted this idea.
    by Disable 01/21/07 09:36 PM
    I used to Skate there...that's not legal either
    by Kathy 01/21/07 08:13 AM
    Finally, the plight of the homeless is in the media. Time for the city to make a legitimate "tent city" with shower and locker facilities, instead of only worrying about building more high end condos. Regardless the reason,this is a community problem
    by Jenni 01/21/07 08:08 AM
    Malicious destruction of property, theft, assault on dignity. Some way to "serve and protect"! The Gestapo is alive and well in St. Pete
    by Dave 01/21/07 07:42 AM
    Sounds like the cops were having a great time picking on the homeless.I hope they had a good nite sleep in there warm beds.They all need better training on how to deal with people.
    by Good Riddence 01/21/07 07:12 AM
    I say "Good Riddence". Excellent Job SPPD. Everyone that says otherwise, let them move onto your steet and let's see what you have to say. Not all, but most of these people are probably able bodied, yet refuse to work. Your hypocracy disgusts me!
    by ted 01/21/07 02:58 AM
    It is not the officers fault, they were just following city hall's orders! City hall is more concerned with open beer violations then drug dealers! god forbid if tourist see homeless people!
    by RJ 01/21/07 02:03 AM
    I am a native of St.Petersburg. I live very close to where this happened. These type of Nazi Police Tactics have totaly shocked and sickened me. People online all over US & Canada have read this story a emailed the Mayor about it. They are quite mad.
    by Shar 01/21/07 01:54 AM
    The national news called St. Petersburg the meanest city in the nation for this action and lack of compassion... I agree. Mayor Baker and the St. Pete police force are a total embarrassment! I'm ashamed to say I live and pay taxes here.
    by Lew 01/21/07 01:02 AM
    I have lived in this city for 42 years, & never have I been more ashamed of this city than NOW. Mayor Baker proves that he & the city only care about the downtown's image. Their only solution to homeless people is brutality. Shame on you Mayor Baker.
    by Greg 01/21/07 12:06 AM
    We are soon moving to St. Pete, and I plan on voting for this Mayor twice.
    by Greg 01/21/07 12:05 AM
    What is the matter with you people? This problem has to be delt with in a firm manner. The message being sent by the city is we don't want you here, please go away. St Pete would turn into something like Calcutta if you just coddle these people
    by Bert 01/21/07 12:03 AM
    Deputy Mayor Metz says " the tents were taken away for evidence " I hope the homeless use them as evidence in a court of law aginst the City of St.Pete. what an ugly mark on a city like St.Pete, Mayor Baker and his cronies need to go.
    by Sharon 01/20/07 10:23 PM
    Lived in St Pete for 14 yrs and NEVER had a homeless person bother me. In fact I always got an extra meal at drive-thru and gave it to them. SPPD obviously had nother better to do
    by Holly 01/20/07 10:09 PM
    Another travesty in the name of public "safety". The cowardice! Another act by police to bully people who have less means and are already down trodden by life. They think no one will stand up for these people, I am happy to see that they ARE WRONG
    by Robert 01/20/07 10:01 PM
    Wow! I just tried to figure out what the heck Candi was trying to say. Yikes! A tent SCHOOL might have been a better idea...
    by Robert 01/20/07 08:58 PM
    I doubt any of the tear jerking - WWJD - they are people TOO, finger pointers in this string would feel the same if these poor people made camp in their neighborhoods or yards.
    by Nicole 01/20/07 08:38 PM
    I lived in St.Pete for seven years and I read the paper everyday, and to hear that the police cut these poor peoples tents makes me sick. These people have no where to go. A tent was their home.
    by All the King's Horses 01/20/07 08:32 PM
    Ohhhh, they don't like the rules.
    by Chris 01/20/07 08:11 PM
    That was so mean what the police did. They could have just bussed them to a more out-of-the-way spot in the county, near the landfill or something. The city should reimburse them for the property damage.
    by Tammy 01/20/07 07:58 PM
    why cant our government help with the homeless situation by providing housing barriks for lets say 6 month or longer if needed allowing the homeless an opertunity to work, provide community services after all this could be us someday, we do live in F
    Subscribe to the Times
    Click here for daily delivery
    of the St. Petersburg Times.

    Email Newsletters

    ADVERTISEMENT