| Political parade By Bill Adair, Times Washington Bureau Chief Democratic and Republican presidential hopefuls campaigned before the nation's largest firefighters union Wednesday. Here's a quick look at what they said and how they acted. |
|||||||||||
| Six Democrats and five Republicans spoke during a marathon campaign forum before the firefighters union March 14. Some of the highlights: | |||||||||||
| Former Sen. John Edwards | Sen. Chris Dodd | Sen. Barack Obama | Gov. Bill Richardson | Sen. Hillary Clinton | Sen. Joe Biden | Sen. John McCain | Sen. Chuck Hagel | Rep. Duncan Hunter | Sen. Sam Brownback | Former Gov. Jim Gilmore | |
| D-N.C. | D-Conn | D-Ill. | D-N.M. | D-N.Y. | D-Del. | R-Ariz | R-Neb. | R-Calif. | R-Kan. | R-Va. | |
| Apparel | Dark suit, blue tie | Dark suit, blue tie | Dark suit, blue and red tie | Dark suit, red striped tie | Gray flowered suit; no tie | Blue dress shirt, blue tie, slacks | Dark suit, red tie | Dark suit, blue tie | Dark suit, blue tie | Dark suit, red tie | Dark suit, red tie |
| Main theme | I support unions | I support unions | I will support veterans and firefighters | I will stand up for the middle class | I will stand up for the middle class | I support unions | We can't cut and run from Iraq | No apparent theme | America should stand tough against enemies | Hope, growth and family | I will defend the homeland |
| Sound bite | "We should have health care for every single man, woman and child in America." | "Working people in this country are feeling the pressure like never, ever before." | "Washington has become a place where politics has become a business instead of a mission." | "We cannot forget the middle class" | "For six long years, our president has not seen the vast majority of Americans." | "The middle class is more uncertain about their future than any time in the last 50 years." | "It's a terrible thing, war - but not the worst thing." | "We have great challenges ahead. We should confront those as Americans always have." | "We're trying to expand freedom in a tough part of the world." | The tax code "deserves to be taken behind a barn and killed with a dull ax." | "When I'm president, the radios are going to work" |
| Why I love firefighters/union members | "I think you are heroes and you deserve people who will stand with you and walk the lines with you." | "Firefighting isn't just about fighting fires." | "It is a noble calling to see a building ablaze and want to rush in." | "You're all heroes" | "I know that for all of you, courage is a job requirement." | Firefighters saved his kids after car crash and responded when lightning struck his house. "We owe you big." | "I’m in the company of heroes here and I am grateful for the privilege." | Sept. 11 "did remind us of who really serves this country." | "Our motto is that when it comes to supporting firefighters, the best politics is no politics" | Praised firefighters who extinguished blaze in his apartment building | "My father was a member of the amalgamated meatcutters for decades and decades." |
| On Iraq | Only made brief reference | Troops need better body armor | "A war that should have never been authorized" | Set deadline for withdrawal, diplomacy with neighbors | "We should end this escalation now" | Praised plan to divide Iraq into three regions | Troop surge looks promising | Not mentioned | "In Iraq, freedom hangs in the balance." | Praised plan to divide Iraq into three regions | Supports troop surge, opposes timetable for withdrawal |
| Key points | Universal health care, support for veterans benefits | Veterans deserve good care, workers should be able to unionize | Veterans deserve better care, the U.S. should leave Iraq | More tax incentives to keep jobs in U.S.; universal health care | Need to equip first responders, stay tough against terrorists | Unions have helped America | First responders need better gear | Sense of community | Need to expand border fence, break down trade barriers | U.S. border should be secured; more U.S. biofuels | Experienced with homeland security, supports Bush on war |
| Rhetorical device/props | Began several examples with "Somewhere in America, there is a (woman/mother/housekeeper) who is (experiencing hardship/walking picket line/unable to get health care for injured child)" | None | Fire metaphors. Said promises to help firefighters "disappear like a puff of smoke." | Self-deprecation. Joked that polls have him at 4 percent. | Repeated references to invisibility. Said many people have become invisible to President Bush | None | Opened with several jokes, including one about drunk Irishmen | None | Mentioned former employee who helped tsunami victims despite having terminal cancer | Held up fabric made in Iowa from wool and corn, to demonstrate U.S. ingenuity | Praised American character; noted that Americans "have thrown the British army off this continent" |
| Surprising element | Spoke less than 14 minutes | Repeatedly referred to "the Dodd Administration" | Brought autographed shirt for union's clothing drive for soldiers | Said he was "pro-gun, pro-owners rights, pro-second amendment." | Veiled reference to husband's infidelity." I have a little experience with staying the course and sticking with people who stick with me." | Didn't wear jacket | Focused heavily on Iraq, an issue that may not win votes | Had no specifics on any issue | Praised Ford Motor Co. for producing bombers during WW II | Wheeled out 3-foot stack of books - the IRS code. | Gave details how he watched 9/11 attack on TV |
| Schtick | Tried to convince the union members that he has special union appeal | Longtime union supporter tries to call in some IOUs | Firefighters and veterans are heroes who deserve better | Second-tier candidate tries light-hearted appeal | Emphasized long friendship with union leaders "Harold and Vinny." | Longtime union supporter tries to call in IOUs | The maverick Republican stands his ground | Wish-washy candidate gives wishy-washy speech | Tried to strike chord on patriotism and trade inequity | Invokes heartland values for union crowd | Emphasized his take-charge work as governor and chairmanship of homeland security panel |