St. Petersburg Times
Special report
Video report
  • For their own good
    Fifty years ago, they were screwed-up kids sent to the Florida School for Boys to be straightened out. But now they are screwed-up men, scarred by the whippings they endured. Read the story and see a video and portrait gallery.
  • More video reports
Multimedia report
Print Email this storyEmail story Comment Email editor
Fill out this form to email this article to a friend
Your name Your email
Friend's name Friend's email
Your message

Welcome back the anti-Bush

By DAVID S. BRODER Washington Post Writers Group
Published April 30, 2007


WASHINGTON - Credit John McCain with one thing: When you're 70 years old, running for president a second time and have been stumping the country for many months, it's difficult to spring any surprises in your formal announcement speech.

The Arizona senator came up with one: He is running as the anti-Bush.

After years of cozying up to the man in the White House, and emerging for better or worse as the most eloquent defender of President Bush's present strategy in Iraq, McCain last week reverted dramatically to his 1999-2000 role as the leading Republican critic of politics as usual.

When he said, in summing up his indictment of present-day Washington, that he wants to change "a bloated, irresponsible and incompetent government, " no one could have doubted whose record he meant.

It is a big gamble on McCain's part, but a necessary one. The closer his ties to Bush have become, the more his standing in the polls has slumped. A poll this month found that more Republicans believe McCain would follow Bush's policies more closely than would Rudy Giuliani or Mitt Romney.

While Bush remains highly popular among Republican voters, GOP consultant Steve Lombardo pointed out that "in no issue area does the (overall) public approve of the president's performance. This is likely to be a 'change' election, " in which the majority of voters seek a new direction, whoever becomes the next president.

So McCain, recognizing that neither Giuliani nor Romney is likely to challenge him from the right, is risking the ire of Bush fans in order to position himself to compete against a Democrat in an election where independents will likely cast the decisive votes.

His campaign aides insist that he has never changed. But this year's McCain gives no emphasis to the campaign finance reforms that were central to his 2000 message, knowing that they are not popular with Republican power brokers. And his announcement speech was notably silent on the subject of immigration reform, another issue on which he has found himself at odds with many of his fellow Republicans.

Still, the theme he sounded last week was the same he had voiced in his first campaign, when he said the nation could not "continue to tolerate a government that has become little more than a spectacle of selfish ambition, a government auctioned to the highest bidder."

Eight years ago, his favorite target was retiring President Bill Clinton, whose personal recklessness had triggered impeachment. "Something has gone terribly wrong when parents no longer want their children to grow up to be president, " McCain said then.

Now, it is the manifest shortcomings of the Bush administration that McCain says he would not tolerate as president. In clear references to the faltering Bush performance on homeland security, Hurricane Katrina relief and Walter Reed hospital treatment of wounded veterans, McCain said: "That's not good enough for America. And when I'm president, it won't be good enough for me."

He used the same words to characterize the failings of the president and Congress on balancing the budget, financing Social Security and Medicare, reforming the tax code, securing energy independence and helping workers who lose their jobs to foreign competition.

And McCain did not exempt Iraq policy from his critique. Instead of underlining his support for attacking Saddam Hussein and his endorsement of Bush's decision to add more troops this year, McCain emphasized the lessons from Iraq.

"We all know the war in Iraq has not gone well, " he said. "We have made mistakes and we have paid grievously for them. We have changed the strategy that failed us, and we have begun to make a little progress. But in the many mistakes we have made in this war, a few lessons have become clear. America should never undertake a war unless we are prepared to do everything necessary to succeed, unless we have a realistic and comprehensive plan for success, and unless all relevant agencies of government are committed to that success. We did not meet this responsibility initially. And we must never repeat that mistake again."

That statement by itself will not appease those who think McCain has been wrong in supporting the war and who deplored his quick embrace of Bush after their bitter struggle in 2000.

But for John McCain, there must be at least some relief now in being able to speak his own mind - whatever the consequences. Candor, even belatedly, becomes him.

David Broder's e-mail address is

[Last modified April 29, 2007, 20:35:29]

Share your thoughts on this story

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Subscribe to the Times
Click here for daily delivery
of the St. Petersburg Times.

Email Newsletters