St. Petersburg Times
Special report
Video report
Multimedia report
Print Email this storyEmail story Comment Letter to the editor
Fill out this form to email this article to a friend
Your name Your email
Friend's name Friend's email
Your message
 

Lead paint forces Thomas toy trains recall

Nearly 1.5-million of the toys made between January 2005 and April 2007 may pose a danger.

By SARAH MISHKIN
Published June 15, 2007


About 4 percent of wooden trains sold by RC2 are affected by the recall. Twenty-six different types of Thomas toys are being recalled, most of which have been painted red or yellow.
photo
[Times photo: Kathleen Flynn]
ADVERTISEMENT
Consumer Product Safety Commission

Parents whose youngsters play with Thomas & Friends wooden trains, take note: Lead in the trains' surface paint has prompted their importer to recall nearly 1.5-million of the popular toys.

The importer, RC2 Corp. of Illinois, announced that the toys, manufactured between January 2005 and April 2007, pose a danger to young children, who are likely to chew on the toys and expose themselves to lead.

The toys were manufactured in Chinese factories not restricted by a 1978 American ban on lead paint domestically.

"The most important thing now is for parents not to delay - this is a serious hazard, " said Scott Wilson, spokesman for the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, which is working with RC2 on the recall. "Parents do need to take the product away from the child."

Wilson said his agency works with Chinese manufacturers to encourage them to meet U.S. safety standards for products exported to this country.

According to a statement by RC2, no illnesses or injuries have been reported as a result of contact with these toys.

Parents in the Tampa Bay area said they were concerned about the potential for exposure to lead paint and other environmental toxins, though many interviewed said their children began playing with the trains after they stopped chewing on their toys.

"They have faces, so they're not just a toy, they're more like a person, " said Ulrica Fraley, of Tampa, whose 4-year-old son Wilson played with the toys.

Dee Dee Bland, whose 9-month-old son, Robby, is too young still for Thomas trains, said she tries to stay aware of potentially dangerous chemicals found in toys and other household objects. Bland stopped using plastic to store her son's food after reading articles in Child magazine about toxic substances that can leech out of it.

Still, she said, it's "probably not enough."

About 4 percent of wooden trains sold by RC2 are affected by the recall. Twenty-six different types of Thomas toys are being recalled, most of which have been painted red or yellow.

Karen Liller, an expert on child injury at the University of South Florida, said lead can accumulate in a child's nervous system, damaging brain development and potentially causing learning difficulties.

"Once that happens, irreversible damage can occur, " she said.

She said symptoms of lead exposure can include loss of appetite, sluggishness and vomiting. A simple blood test for lead can be done on children as young as 6 months, and she said parents should contact their pediatrician or their local health department if they are concerned.

In the meantime, parents should be open with their children about why they can't play with some of their toys anymore, said Anne Eason, a licensed child psychologist in South Tampa. Children will notice if some of their toys just disappear, and Eason suggests parents make a small ritual of boxing up the Thomas trains to return them to the manufacturer.

"These particular trains are almost objects of obsession with some kids, " said Eason, who said her daughters used to love Thomas trains. "Recognize that kids are going to have a grief reaction."

Sarah Mishkin can be reached at smishkin@sptimes.com or 813 225 3110.

FAST FACTS

What parents should do

Visit recalls.rc2.com or call 866-725-4407 to get information on returning recalled items for an exchange.

Manufacturing codes are located on the bottom of the product. Toys labelled "WJ" or "AZ" are not included in the recall.

Concerned parents can call their child's pediatrician and request a blood test for lead.

[Last modified June 15, 2007, 00:54:44]


Share your thoughts on this story

Comments on this article
by Pam 09/20/07 11:58 AM
One year of zero spending (buy used stuff)even by as few as 1 million people would have an impact. The issue doesn't end with toys. No one can make us buy Nafta. Every dollar we spend, and where we spend it says exactly what we really value most.
by MRH 08/16/07 09:40 PM
Hey America, why dont you send some more of OUR jobs over to China?
by N 08/15/07 05:39 PM
RC2 should be forthcoming and provide us with a indiv. list of which of our products are toxic from those we sent back. Bottomline, I want to know if my child was exposed for sure and if my chewed train was one that contained lead.
by Cindy 08/02/07 12:08 AM
My husb. & I will not to buy things made in China again. If we have to go without it, oh well. This is where we all need to start if we want to reclaim our American production. It's all about supply and demand. Don't just complain about it. Do it.
by Melissa 07/20/07 07:58 AM
Made in China. Radio Flier, Graco, Fischer Price, Baby Einstein...etc. We wonder why there is a high prevelence of Autism in our children when all of the products we get for our children are made in China using material that isn't tested for toxins.
by Melissa 07/20/07 07:52 AM
I have concerns over products made in China. There have been some real problems brought to light over the substandard products from China. I have a one year old. I went to toys r us to get her toys for her birthday and every product was made in China
by jim 06/20/07 11:21 AM
China will always have these issues. I would imagine there a whole lot more painted toys that have the same issue. The toys are not cheap if you have bought one for your child. American's better wake up an smell the coffee. More problems to come
by jim 06/20/07 11:20 AM
China will always have these issues. I would imagine there a whole lot more painted toys that have the same issue. The toys are not cheap if you have bought one for your child. American's better wake up an smell the coffee. More problems to come
by Carl 06/19/07 07:04 PM
When is our President going to act? Three incidents in the last two months that have come to light. That means there are hundreds more that are sliding through. Does anyone in charge give a damn??
by Al 06/18/07 08:58 PM
Not only are we loosing American jobs'but we are financing the Chinese war machine,nuclear and space.
by Steve 06/18/07 02:31 PM
Thank Clinton for our relationship with China. Ross Perot warned us about NAFTA, and no one heeded.
by rob 06/18/07 02:02 AM
And everyone was scared of Japan,too.It forced us not into making quality stuff but selling out.
by pete 06/18/07 01:45 AM
and this has been going on since 2005!!! children and younger siblings kid have had ample time to completely consume all the tasty paint by now! Asia is well known for human rights issues, & worse for children's rights!
by HapticZ 06/18/07 01:29 AM
if companies sub-contract to known areas with little/no control over their product quality, then they are directly legally responsible for damages and liability. timeline wise, this was known months ago! yet another Chinese human rights issue!
by randall 06/18/07 01:26 AM
We really need a tariff on China, so we could have the resources to catch these prior to harming us. I guess we won't be proud of Made in America, till our kids, pets and even we die. Thanks Walmart!
by sara 06/17/07 10:04 PM
Stop sending our products and toys to be made in china and other countries and do the right thing and keep it in AMERICA IN THE USA..........GOD BLESS AMERICA AMEN!!!!!!!!!!!!
by SN 06/17/07 09:52 PM
"China-Free" would be a great marketing point.
by Ropertex 06/17/07 09:13 PM
When we open the floodgates to food and products from a communist country, which the military and government own the factories, what should we expect? Thanks, Nixon....
by Joe 06/17/07 06:22 PM
Sarah Mishkin, look up "leech" and "leach."
by j 06/17/07 06:21 PM
Imagine, chinese factory using lead paint on toys destined for american kids... is anyone surprised
by Al Atzinger 06/17/07 06:10 PM
A law to keep production in America. No, let's just have some national pride and common sense and build the toys (& Colgate toothpaste) in the USA. We are putting our health and that of our children in the hands of Communist China. It's sad.
by Ray 06/17/07 02:07 PM
Sure you can prosecute, but by that time it's too late, some child has been harmed. Bring back production to the home market until such time as offshore companies can demonstrate proper environmental and safety procedures are in place.
by Jack 06/17/07 01:56 PM
Don't always blame Chinese. Its the drive from Wall St. and greed. Why doesn't the importer have a QC standard for manufacturing?
by Sandy 06/17/07 01:45 PM
I agree with posters who say keep production in America! That's a no-brainer! Keep production in America and put American workers to work before the economy completely tanks!
by Jason 06/17/07 01:31 PM
Maybe not a law to keep production in America, but it's becoming clear that any product tainted with materials from China has to be clearly marked as possibly toxic, including FOOD. There is now a story every week about poisonous exports from China.
by Jon 06/17/07 12:12 PM
Please-- grow up. American companies have/can be, at minimum, as guilty of doing everything for the all mighty dollar. Easy example are those sites indicated as Superfund toxic clean-up sites.
by Noel 06/17/07 11:54 AM
Is sad and incredible that we can trust anything this times not even a simple toy, now imagine dental creme that claim hundreds of deads in latin american countrys, manufacture in China i don't think they care, i don't think they will.
by Kay 06/17/07 11:49 AM
Americans should band together and go without until the production of our goods is brought back to the USA!
by Concerned 06/17/07 11:41 AM
I am sure we would be amazed at the number of poducts a typical Wal-Mart sells that are toxic to our kids, pets, and us. The onus should be on the importer to test the products they import for lead and other common toxins.
by Koran 06/17/07 11:33 AM
Using plastic to store food can create toxic materials...even they are all made in US. Blaming China for every evil is just the simplest way to do.
by Carl 06/17/07 11:25 AM
World Trade!!! China isn't covered by our consumer protections. Back to the old days... Let the buyer beware. But we're complacent. We get what we asked for, cheep goods from overseas. Loss of jobs here, support of slavery and corruption there.
by Bruce 06/17/07 11:17 AM
Safety testing (including lead content) is standard for all children's toys - if RC2 didn't do this, it is entirely their fault.
by Andy 06/17/07 05:10 AM
A law to keep production in America? We've seen your American cars...it might not be lethal but sure heck isnt acceptable either. Do what Jim says instead, prosecute the companies that are doing this irresponsible acts.
by Gina 06/16/07 12:19 PM
I believe that there should be guide lines , not only for products made in other countries though for all products made for children in America and other countries.
by sonya 06/16/07 10:51 AM
Thats the kind of thing we as americans have to deal with everyday when companies go over seas to save a buck!!! If the governmemt would make a law to keep these companies here we all would be better off!!!!!!!!!!!!
Subscribe to the Times
Click here for daily delivery
of the St. Petersburg Times.

Email Newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT