Print

Email story

Comment

Letter to the editor

Homeless man wins panhandling case

Since he stayed on a median, it's legal. Though city codes prohibit it in some other areas.

By ABHI RAGHUNATHAN
Published June 19, 2007

Steve Angel is all smiles outside the South Pinellas County Courthouse as he chats with his girlfriend, Maryann Cooney (left) and his attorney, Summer Vecchioli of the Fleming Law Group, after his panhandling ticket was dismissed Monday.
	[Times photo: Cherie Diez]

ADVERTISEMENT [Times photo: Cherie Diez] After Steve Angel (left) was fined, he told his friends at the Fleming Law Group, who agreed to help.

ST. PETERSBURG - Steve Angel didn't just shrug when he was given a $73.50 fine for panhandling. He fought the citation in court.

On Monday, he won.

After listening to a few minutes of testimony and arguments, Judge William Overton found Angel not guilty. As he sauntered out, Angel smiled and held two thumbs up.

Officer Nicolas Bevan said he cited Angel, 49, after he saw him holding a sign asking for money. The reason: "conducting business on median."

But as Summer Vecchioli, Angel's attorney, pointed out, panhandling on a median is perfectly legal under the statute the officer accused Angel of violating. Plus, Vecchioli got officer Bevan to admit that he hadn't seen Angel walk into the streets or solicit any business. He was standing on the median, smiling and holding a sign.

"He was simply asking for a donation," she said.

Angel, who is homeless, spends most nights in the parking lot behind the Fleming Law Group, and considers attorney Lucas Fleming and other employees friends. When he told them about his May 5 citation, the law practice decided to represent him.

Officer Bevan declined to comment after the hearing. Police spokesman Bill Proffitt said officers would be told to cite panhandlers under the state statute only if they stepped off medians and into roadways. City codes prohibit panhandling in some other areas, like parts of downtown and near ATMs.

"The ruling makes sense given what the statute says," Proffitt said.

Cecilia Miller, 56, who has seen Angel panhandling, showed up at court and gave him $40 for dinner after the judge's decision.

"I'm just so happy right now," Angel said, holding his girlfriend Maryann Cooney's hand. "I'm just so, so happy."

Times photographer Cherie Diez contributed to this report. Abhi Raghunathan can be reached at araghunathan@sptimes.com or 727 893-8372.

[Last modified June 19, 2007, 00:00:59]