News
Fill out this form to email this article to a friend
Politics
Either agree or stay home
A tax-funded summit on disabilities and "inclusion" excludes dissenters.
By STEVE BOUSQUET
Published June 19, 2007
TALLAHASSEE - A taxpayer-funded, invitation-only conference on caring for people with developmental disabilities opened amid controversy Monday at an elegant Orlando hotel.
The event has reopened old wounds between two groups with fiercely held opposing views: those who consider institutions a suitable setting for people with disabilities, and those who consider that "segregation."
"Because it is so contentious, and we represent and serve all people, it was recommended that I not attend, " said Jane Johnson, director of the Agency for Persons with Disabilities. "It's not right for the agency to come down on one side or the other. We serve people in all settings."
Johnson said her absence was prompted in part by e-mails sent to Gov. Charlie Crist and other state officials, criticizing the summit, which began with a reception and dinner Monday at the Peabody Hotel in Orlando.
The three-day "Inclusion Now! Summit" is being hosted by the Florida Developmental Disabilities Council, which draws most of its budget from federal funds.
The goal, an organizer said, is to encourage people with disabilities to become more integrated in society, rather than living in group homes or institutions.
"What we want to do is create more choices, " said organizer Nila Benito of Lutz, the council's treasurer and mother of two autistic sons, who works on issues for the University of South Florida.
People with disabilities, she said, "are the last minority that it appears okay to segregate."
About 80 people are attending the all-expense-paid summit. Benito confirmed that only people who support the choice concept were invited.
"The first criteria was people who were change agents, who already have a belief in inclusion, " Benito said.
But what Benito calls choice, some families worry is a campaign to close down group homes and institutions.
"This is an abuse, and it's not right, " said Don Stover of New Port Richey, who e-mailed his complaints to state officials.
Stover said his son has lived for 40 years at a state-run mental institution in Fort Myers.
"Our son has had a good life, and they're giving him the best of care, " said Stover, who called Benito "a very stubborn old lady."
Stover and others have written to Crist and legislators, asking why the council can use public funds to exclude people from a conference devoted to the theme of "inclusion."
Benito said anyone can attend events where public comment will be taken, but not at the working-group seminars. She added she would meet personally with anyone critical of the conference.
The summit comes at a time when families of the developmentally disabled are reeling from steep state cuts in services, implemented by the Legislature to close an agency budget deficit.
The disabilities council's project budget summary shows a payment of $126, 000 for the "inclusion summit research and facilitation, " to be paid to Syracuse University, another $133, 000 for a "grass roots campaign" and a $19, 000 fee to an "inclusion summit planner."
Debra Dowds, the council's executive director, said the group got discounts for $129-a-night rooms and free meeting rooms, but added: "The cost of the food is exorbitant."
Dowds said that under federal law, the council must work to build "inclusive communities."
"We want people to be in the community. We want them living in their own home, " Dowds said. "And we're going to invite people who believe in that."
Steve Bousquet can be reached at bousquet@sptimes.com or 850 224-7263.
[Last modified June 19, 2007, 03:57:29]
Share your thoughts on this story
Comments on this article
|
by Bob
|
06/27/07 10:00 PM
|
|
Check the time the messages on the 24th and the 25th were written. Just do that. Nila, how long did it take you to make up the names? And sainthood? Please! To whom? Inclusion? For whom? 80 of your nearest and dearest friends? You should be ashamed!
|
|
by Beth
|
06/27/07 09:57 PM
|
|
For goodness sake! How can anyone associated with The ARC fail to recognize that every word spoken at this swank "summit" was a direct attack on Floridians' right to choose. Inclusion without choice is not inclusion at all. It's an expensive sham.
|
|
by Mark
|
06/27/07 09:55 PM
|
|
If Nila Benito is a saint, God Bless people with disabilities throughout Florida. The one altar this lady worships at is that of her employer, the University of South Florida and its interests. Grow up, people! Pick good saints!
|
|
by Tony
|
06/26/07 12:25 AM
|
|
As a father of a young disabled man, I have to fight for my son to be included in school, in the community, and at work. But the state would easily place him in an institution in a heart beat. Thank you FDDC for making inclusion happen!
|
|
by Maria
|
06/25/07 10:25 PM
|
|
Inclusion is a right. Segregation is a punishment. Jane Johnson needs a wake up call about right from wrong.
|
|
by Tom
|
06/25/07 11:37 AM
|
|
I am director of an ARC and am grateful to Nila, Debra, and the FDDC for moving services toward inclusion and better outcomes for the disabled.
|
|
by Jose
|
06/25/07 11:36 AM
|
|
God Bless the DD Council. They are the only ones who are out there doing what needs to be done to protect the rights of the most severely disabled in Florida. We need more summits like this!
|
|
by Rose
|
06/25/07 11:31 AM
|
|
Thank you FDDC. Stand strong and Keep Up the good work. The disabled in Florida need more people like you.
|
|
by Tammy
|
06/25/07 11:30 AM
|
|
Nila Benito is a saint! The Inclusion Now summit is a breakthrough for Florida and for the civil rights of people with disabilities.
|
|
by Joanne
|
06/24/07 11:42 PM
|
|
Martin Luther King was assassinated and in 2007 the people who donò019t agree with the basic human right of inclusion are trying to do assassinate the character of people on the FDDC. Yes Governor Crist,take notice and give the FDDC a medal of honor!
|
|
by Susan
|
06/24/07 11:36 PM
|
|
Why are people angry about inclusion? Maybe they come from the families of the people who opposed integration of Blacks in the 1960's. Segration is ONLY okay for the people in our prisions! It's not okay for people with disabilities!
|
|
by Mark
|
06/24/07 11:33 PM
|
|
The FDDC is mandated by the FERDERAL Government to use their funds for systems change activities that will implement the DD Act. The plan developed at the summit will do just that! It's sad to see the people are mad when this is wonderful for Florida
|
|
by Nancy
|
06/24/07 11:29 PM
|
|
ItThe Summit was about Human Rights. Leading experts in community living, employment, education, and healthcare in our state along with families and individuals with disabilities worked worked very hard, from early in the morning until late night.
|
|
by Nicole
|
06/24/07 11:27 PM
|
|
I want to thank the FDDC for their commitment and the financial support it took to bring together such an amazing group of leaders toa plan to move our state into a seamless system that does not discriminate or segregate individuals with disabilities
|
|
by Mike
|
06/24/07 11:25 PM
|
|
This criticism is unfounded and partisan. The summit was a call to action to emphasize that EVERYONE benefits when the civil rights and innate potential of ALL individuals are recognized and supported in all aspects of community life."
|
|
by Joe
|
06/24/07 11:23 PM
|
|
The Inclusion Now! Summit beautifully articulated message of the disability rights movement at large. Thank you FDDC!!!!
|
|
by Robert
|
06/23/07 10:21 AM
|
|
Here we go again! They're moaning again, the same people Senator Storms said were inside the all-you-can-eat restaurant looking at the thousands who can't get in. Rich people getting richer while the poor get left out in the cold. And where's Crist?
|
|
by Beth
|
06/22/07 08:47 AM
|
|
A friend at The ARC suggested I read this article and I'm glad to find the comment section. This group is notorious for scaring people and diving our disability community, all with funds from the feds. It's time for a change, Gov. Crist. Honestly!
|
|
by Lynda
|
06/22/07 07:26 AM
|
|
Steve Bousquet did a great job exposing this group's excesses and lack of regulatory supervision. To spend that kind of money on something so frivolous is a clear-cut violation of the public trust and I agree Governor Crist should throw them out!
|
|
by David
|
06/21/07 09:24 PM
|
|
Debra Dowds, the council's executive director, said the group got discounts for $129-a-night rooms and free meeting rooms, but added: "The cost of the food is exorbitant." Isn't there a Burker King a couple of blocks down the street, Miss Dowds?
|
|
by Rocky
|
06/21/07 09:05 PM
|
|
My son is 7,345 on the APD's waiting list for waiver services and these people have the nerve to spend 3 days at The Peabody, in Orlando, living the high life! For shame! Gov. Crist, throw these bums out! Tonight! So much for open government!
|
|
by Mary
|
06/21/07 05:45 PM
|
|
A dream built on the ego of one person who believes her vision is the ONLY vision is neither a dream nor a vision anyone who thinks the United States is a land built on choice can support. The time to change the membership of this Council is NOW!
|
|
by Lilly
|
06/21/07 09:48 AM
|
|
"THE TIME TO END SEGREGATION OF PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES IS NOW!" Thank you FDDC for the Inclusion Summit! Let's continue to build upon our Call to Action to end the segregation of children, youth and adults with disabilities in FL. WE HAVE A DREAM!
|
|
by Kevin
|
06/20/07 09:23 AM
|
|
Laura, you are exactly right. Some individuals with disabilities are not able to live at home. That's the problem!!! These are individuals who have all the hopes and desires of any typical human being. They need the support to realize goals!
|
|
by Steve
|
06/20/07 12:15 AM
|
|
Federal tax money should not be used to promote discrimination in any way, shape or form. Don't we have any laws against this abuse of the use of Federal tax money. No wonder our taxes are going up and services down along with free speech gone.
|
|
by Cheryl
|
06/19/07 02:46 PM
|
|
So much for debate and Freedom of Speech. I don't see how exclusion could be legal, using taxpayer dollars. What are we in the USSR?
|
|
by Laura
|
06/19/07 02:44 PM
|
|
Hah - no wonder taxes are so high. Why not take this money and help the disabled?? By the way, some diabled are not able to live at home - I'm not sure why this conference is even being held.
|
|
by Connie
|
06/19/07 12:51 PM
|
|
How can this be good for such a fragile segment of our society to be excluded. I have a son that is living in a state facility living a very rewarding life. We had a choice which is vital for him. When did CHOICE become non essential part of life?
|
|
by JB
|
06/19/07 12:23 PM
|
|
You friggin idiots. There are 18,000 people on the wait list for services. APD caps individual spending @ $14k/yr. So without this conference, you could've served or 'included' almost 20 people. Repeat first sentence.
|
|
by Scott
|
06/19/07 08:02 AM
|
|
How can this possibly be a good use of federal tax dollars or anyones tax dollars fro that matter? If the attendees had to pay their own way would anyone attend - doubtful. End this kind of waste NOW!
|