News
Fill out this form to email this article to a friend
Bush squads stifle free speech
A Times Editorial
Published August 31, 2007
Had President George W. Bush been running the country in 1773 instead of King George III, the historically significant protest known as the Boston Tea Party might never have taken place. The patriots disguised as Indians would have been denied entry to the docks where the British ships laden with tea were moored, or surrounded and shouted down by royal "rally squads," or arrested by the king's police.
Sound ludicrous? Take a look at a 12-page document recently released by the White House with the title "Presidential Advance Manual." (It's available online at www.aclu.org with a search of the title.)
Stamped "Sensitive - Do Not Copy" on its cover, the manual instructs the president's staff on how to squelch legitimate protest at a presidential event. It was made public only after the American Civil Liberties Union subpoenaed documents in a lawsuit on behalf of two protesters who were arrested at a Bush speech. Parts of the manual are redacted, but plenty of details remain to paint a disturbing picture of the administration's disdain for dissent.
First, the manual instructs, try to spot any potential protesters outside the event so they can be denied admission tickets. Only a "trusted local volunteer" is allowed to distribute tickets, which should be given only to those involved in the event or "other groups extremely supportive of the administration." The word "extremely" is underlined in the manual so there is no mistake.
To prevent demonstrators who might have obtained a ticket from entering the event, organizers are instructed to turn back those who appear to have "folded cloth signs." If protesters still slip through, they are to be countered by "rally squads" loyal to the president, whose members could include "college/Young Republican organizations, local athletic teams and fraternities/sororities."
The rally squads are to use their own banners to shield the demonstrators' signs from "the main press platform." Should the demonstrators express themselves verbally, the manual goes on, "rally squads can begin and lead supportive chants to drown out the protesters (USA! USA! USA!)." For good measure, "one squad should be 'roaming' throughout the perimeter of the event to look for potential problems."
Of course prevention of free speech is always the best choice, according to the manual: "First, as always, work with the Secret Service and have them ask the local police department to designate a protest area where demonstrators can be placed, preferably not in view of the event site or motorcade route." Heaven forbid Bush hear a word of dissent.
The ACLU is representing two people who were arrested at a Bush speech when they refused to cover up their T-shirts printed with these messages: "Regime Change Starts at Home" and "Love America, Hate Bush." The man and woman were handcuffed and briefly jailed before police dropped the charges and apologized.
Hard to believe all of this is happening not in Putin's Russia or Castro's Cuba but in Bush's America, where secret squads suppress free speech lest someone hear a discouraging word.
[Last modified August 30, 2007, 23:00:55]
Share your thoughts on this story
Comments on this article
|
by Steve
|
09/08/07 04:18 AM
|
|
The greatest fear our troops have is being killed or maimed in Bush's War. The greatest fear of those who love and support it is the miliary draft might be restored and they would be forced to fight in it. A great idea; Let's restore the draft.
|
|
by Walter
|
09/03/07 11:47 AM
|
|
I feel we are carrying this freedom of whatever way to far. These sign bearers are a minority in this country but seem to make the most noise. The ACLU we can do without. What we need to do is protect this country, it is the greatest in the world.
|
|
by Monty
|
09/02/07 08:38 AM
|
|
Note to Kevin, Pete and others. The ACLU,that you say looks out for Americans, was founded in the 1920`s by American Communists loyal to Stalin, NOT America. One of the founders dying in Moscow. Google Elizabeth Gurley Flynn. Try to be Informed.
|
|
by Evan
|
09/02/07 06:33 AM
|
|
Anyone who thinks that the Bush Staff are the only ones to have a manual regarding the above,need only to go back to the Clinton era and how they also controlled the dissenters.
|
|
by JB
|
09/01/07 04:04 AM
|
|
Republicans, please take responsibility for your actions for once. Stop blaming the "liberal Media", bad advisors etc for the utter incompetence of the Bush Administration. Bush alone is responsible for this fiasco.
|
|
by Phil
|
09/01/07 02:18 AM
|
|
It is sad to see these pro Bush republicans trying to defend and justify the destruction of the principles of free speech this country was founded on. They are pro Bush hypocrites. Their actions are unpatriotic and, un-American.
|
|
by J
|
09/01/07 12:08 AM
|
|
Bush is not a dictator. He is an honest man, but he has flaws just like anyone else.
To compare him to Stalin or Hitler is simply ludicrous.
|
|
by Sylvia
|
08/31/07 04:33 PM
|
|
Bill, it wasn't a private function, that's the problem! It was held in a public space, paid for by taxpayers, therefore Bush had no business shuting them up, or else he needs to rent a space and pay for it... this country is getting scarry!
|
|
by Kelly
|
08/31/07 11:41 AM
|
|
Did anyone beside myself see the TV coverage of Hillary Clinton doing the EXACT SAME THING?? This article is just another example of the "elite" media doing everything in its power to destroy anyone with conservative leanings.
|
|
by Bill
|
08/31/07 11:09 AM
|
|
There is a difference in suppressing free speech, and suppressing attendance at a private function. I'm no fan of bush, but if he wants to limit his input that's his right. History will record he is a narrow minded fool.
|
|
by Carol
|
08/31/07 10:49 AM
|
|
This is why Bush seemed to rule in a bubble for 6 years; he's BEEN in one. Better/different advisors may have stopped the terrible incompetency of his administration: Iraq, Katrina, NSA Spying, Abu Ghraid, Distr. Atty firings. The list goes on and on
|
|
by LeRoy
|
08/31/07 10:39 AM
|
|
This is NOTHING compared to the dirty tricks the Clintons have pulled (even on their own democrats). They have their henchmen who work behind the scenes and go stealth. Even O'Bama has seen it from Hillary already (with much more to come).
|
|
by DEnnis
|
08/31/07 10:23 AM
|
|
Kevein made my point, it isn't right but when was the last time you heard the press cry about it from a liberal president. Don't demonize Bush and make him out to be something differant than the rest.
|
|
by JIm
|
08/31/07 10:20 AM
|
|
They should be able to keep the freaks quiet. Weidos with nothing to do but protest. Gimme a break
|
|
by Angelo
|
08/31/07 09:42 AM
|
|
Bush and Company apparently never bothered to read the U S Constitution, as many Americans. We really need to teach this in our public schools so we understand the limits of political power.
|
|
by Carlos
|
08/31/07 09:14 AM
|
|
Free speech zones are nothing new. This is not an invention of the Bush admin as the writer wants everyone to believe. Brant is correct, the open exchange of ideas has NEVER been more vibrant (like this right here).
|
|
by Brant
|
08/31/07 08:29 AM
|
|
This is a piffle. Free speech has never been more vibrant in this country. Think what would have happened to a jerk like Michael Moore during the Civil War or WWII.
|
|
by Pete
|
08/31/07 08:21 AM
|
|
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) is watchdog groups trying to make sure EVERY Americaṇ019s Civil Liberties are not denied. Even Rush Limbaugh needed their help! They are on the side of the people, last time I checked, WE ran this country!
|
|
by Kevin
|
08/31/07 08:18 AM
|
|
The ACLU actively defends and protects our Bill of Rights in the judicial system. I can see where tyrants, bigots and neocons would be terrified by its pro-citizen agenda. Other presidents did it? Tu quoque fallacy. Doesn't make it right or American.
|
|
by Dennis
|
08/31/07 06:39 AM
|
|
What palnet are you from? Do you really think Bush is the first president to limit access to an event? They ALL do it. But you would never hear that from the ACLU,they have one thought in mind,undermine anything American.
|
|
by Boo Boo
|
08/31/07 05:39 AM
|
|
This is the Amerika he built. For all of you that don't realize it. For the past 7 yrs you have been living in a Dictatorship. I guess this is mild compared to the 60's when we got our heads bashed in. I wonder if thats the part that is blacked out.
|