St. Petersburg Times
Special report
Video report
  • For their own good
    Fifty years ago, they were screwed-up kids sent to the Florida School for Boys to be straightened out. But now they are screwed-up men, scarred by the whippings they endured. Read the story and see a video and portrait gallery.
  • More video reports
Multimedia report
Print Email this storyEmail story Comment Letter to the editor
Fill out this form to email this article to a friend
Your name Your email
Friend's name Friend's email
Your message
 

Nursing mom asked to stop

A teacher and principal request no breast-feeding at school; the law's on mom's side.

By Times Staff Writer
Published February 17, 2008


ADVERTISEMENT

ST. PETERSBURG - Alicia Norris was enjoying lunch with her daughter while visiting her at Rio Vista Elementary School, and thought nothing of the fact that she was nursing her 19-month-old son Tahoma while sitting at a picnic table outside.

That is, until a teacher approached her and told her she could not breast-feed her baby on school property.

"Most people don't even notice that you're nursing. There were other children walking by on the sidewalk and nobody even looked at me. There was no gawking or anything," said Norris, who has two children attending Rio Vista Elementary.

"I have never been asked to stop," she said. "I think this shows a lack of education in an educational environment." She told the teacher she did not care to discuss it in front of her older child, and continued.

Later the same day, she said, school principal Wayne Whitney approached - she was not nursing at the time - and again asked her not to breast-feed at the school.

As Norris sees it, a school of all places should be family friendly and this one seemed anything but. "I felt degraded," she said of the Oct. 29 incident. "I've been nursing three children for nine years and I've never felt like that before."

Florida law states that women can breast-feed anywhere in public or private as long as they are in that place legally.

"I do hear about incidents like this quite a bit," said Heidi Buck, a local leader of La Leche League, a support group for nursing mothers. "I don't think it happens as much as it used to but it's still not uncommon. It goes back to the old way of thinking that breasts are sexual things.

"But breast-feeding is not a sexual thing. It's a natural means of feeding and nurturing your child."

Norris fired off a letter to Pinellas County school superintendent Clayton Wilcox, citing the Florida law.

The statute states: "A mother may breast-feed her baby in any location, public or private, where the mother is otherwise authorized to be, irrespective of whether the nipple of the mother's breast is uncovered during or incidental to the breast-feeding."

Principal Whitney later looked into Florida law on breast-feeding, and found he was off-base, said Pinellas School Board spokeswoman Andrea Zahn. He has since told staff members that breast-feeding is allowed at school.

"We don't have a specific School Board policy but we certainly conform to the state statutes," she added.

"A couple teachers expressed their concerns," said Whitney. "I asked her not to do it in front of small children."

Norris said she has been back to Rio Vista and nursed her son about four times since the incident, but has chosen to do so at a more secluded table behind the kindergarten playground.

"I feel very uncomfortable around the principal and the other teacher who approached me," she said. "I felt like they were looking at me like I was doing something wrong or dirty."

Norris said she just wants to make sure people at the school and elsewhere know the rules. "I don't need an apology," she said.

She said Whitney has since called to acknowledge that she could breast-feed on the campus.

"It would just be nice if they could say we were mistaken and we hope you don't feel uncomfortable here," she said. "I'm not going to let somebody tell me that I'm not going to feed my baby."

[Last modified February 19, 2008, 16:22:59]


Share your thoughts on this story

Comments on this article
by Suzie 02/27/08 01:08 PM
"Norris said she has been back to Rio Vista and nursed her son about four times since the incident". So what's your beef--why go to the paper. She just wants attention.
by JH 02/27/08 10:34 AM
It's also legal in Florida for a man to walk around w/o a shirt. What if this had been a 400 pound man with no shirt on. It's legal. Big gut, hairy back, stinky, it's natural too. There you are stooopid liberals, figure out your PC response to this.
by Stephanie 02/27/08 07:12 AM
Have some common sense Alicia! You were not sitting there nursing a baby you were nursing a TODDLER! quite obvious when when was hanging off your lap where as a baby the kids/teacher might not even noticed. Was he eating his happy mealthen too?
by Rio Staff 02/24/08 09:27 PM
Folks, please understand that this kid isn't an infant and has been known to eat a McDonald's Happy Meal prior to nursing. It's not as if he's being asked to starve for 30 minutes. Why is this such a big deal? Discretion is all that was asked of her.
by Merry 02/23/08 12:17 PM
Well what about the freaking needs of the BABY???? Hunger IS a need you uptight folks!!!! And it was EVERYONE elses lunchtime! Get over it.
by Rio Mom 02/21/08 08:33 PM
Hallie -breast milk is great. If she can't feed that child before/after her visit to the school then she should PUMP in advance and use a bottle in front of the other kids. I should be able to educate my son on that subject when I feel HE is ready.
by Hallie 02/21/08 06:25 PM
How does it violate anyone else's rights? We need to get our children used to the site of a nursing mom, to help change the view of it, we're coming of a generation that was told formula was better and now we have to fix that! breast is best
by Rio Teacher 02/21/08 04:58 PM
What of the rights of the OTHER parents and their children? Why are the rights of ONE mother valued over those of the majority?! Yes, she has a right, but her right is stepping on those of others. Where do we draw the line?
by Shannon 02/20/08 06:24 PM
I am a teacher and a breastfeeding mom as well and I would certainly welcome and embrace another breastfeeding mother into my classroom. I think we must be proud and supportive of one another and teach our young children to do the same.
by Teacher/Breastfeeding Mom 02/20/08 02:14 PM
To my understanding, the article refrained from mentioning that it was happening in a class of 22. That is NOT acceptable. That causes a distraction to the learning that needs to happen. When breastfeeding in public,use wise discrestion.
by Skippy 02/20/08 02:07 PM
It is time to NIP this in the bud !!!!
by Joan 02/20/08 11:18 AM
There are 2 sides to every story and this article was obviously very 1 sided. It is not a teachers job to explain to a 5 year old or a 5th grader why a woman's breast is exposed. As a mother I think this mother could have been more discreet!
by Paula 02/19/08 08:36 PM
I nursed my children and I would nurse whenever and wherever they needed to be nursed. I was not concerned with others. I was focused on feeding my baby. The BREAST is for BREAST-FEEDING and the best source of nutrients and comfort for the baby.
by Raddy 02/19/08 06:52 PM
ò01CTommy the Mommy is breastfeeding her child because she loves him soooo much and wants to give him the best she can. Breast milk is very good for children; it makes them strong, healthy and happy. Does that help?
by Jessica 02/19/08 06:01 PM
The World Health Organization recommends breastfeeding for "2 years or beyond". The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends breastfeeding for at least the first year. The experts say this is the right thing to do... yes even in PUBLIC!
by Dora 02/19/08 02:33 PM
While I agree that women have the right to breast feed their child in public, as long as they are respective of the people around them, i have to ask: why is this considered news?
by bridget 02/19/08 09:33 AM
The law is on her side. That is all there is to it.
by leshea 02/19/08 08:39 AM
i have a relative breast feeding. by not educating my own daughter, i became horrified when she walked across the room and pulled up her shirt. she thought her breast fell out. if we educate our children, they think nothing of a natural feeding.
by Michelle 02/18/08 08:56 AM
Yes, mothers have the RIGHT to breastfeed in public. I think she should have used better judgement. At an elementary school?! Not to mention, the child is almost 2!!!!
by Ellen 02/18/08 08:05 AM
In defense of Mr. Whitney and the teacher...school staff keep up-to-date on the lastest strategies for teaching reading, writing and math. Why should they be educated on an act that should be kept to a private setting and not in front of children!
by another Rio parent 02/18/08 12:49 AM
No one said don't feed your baby (i.e. toddler). Just have some respect for the other children, teachers should not have to explain your actions to my son. You seem very self-absorbed. You clearly are doing this for attention, get a hobby.
by Kathy 02/17/08 11:59 PM
I also nursed three children; however, a 19-month-old child can easily refrain for the 30 minutes this mother spends with her child at school. The students and teachers also have a right go about the school's daily business without such distraction.
by Carol 02/17/08 12:07 PM
Breast feeders need to think of cleanliness. Years ago we washed I was taught to wash my breast before feeding. Outside or in the mall certainly doesn't allow for that.I think deordorant, sweat, etc might not taste so great for the kid.
by erin 02/17/08 11:30 AM
In a country where breastfeeding mothers are the minority and since everyone knows it is best for babies, women should not be discouraged to BF under any circumstances. It might be different if there were nice places for mothers to BF while in public
by Angie 02/17/08 11:22 AM
Right Jean... And as human beings we should only eat in the privacy of our own homes. Eating in public is disgusting. hahaha! It's just breast feeding folks. It's not only perfectly natural, it's good for the baby.
by Erin 02/17/08 11:05 AM
Some activities shoulb be conducted in private but breastfeeding is NOT one of them. I refusize to hide myself away just because I have chosen what is best and most natural for my baby. Get over it, it's just a boob -- covered by a blanket.
by Florida Mom 02/17/08 10:30 AM
Jesus was breastfed. I don't understand why the principal, the teacher and Jean take such an anti-child view.
by Jean 02/17/08 04:56 AM
Some activities should be conducted in private. Breast feeding is one of them.
Subscribe to the Times
Click here for daily delivery
of the St. Petersburg Times.

Email Newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT