News
Fill out this form to email this article to a friend
Woman can't let grandson, a Jehovah's Witness, die 'in vain'
Olga Lindberg remains consumed by the idea that her grandson died because of misguided faith, and she is driven to share her belief.
By Andrew Meacham, Times Staff Writer
Published February 24, 2008
|
Olga Lindberg takes a moment to compose herself in the grocery store after talking with strangers about her grandson's death from leukemia after he refused blood transfusions.
|
 |
|
[Lara Cerri | Times]
|
|
ADVERTISEMENT
 |
|
[Lara Cerri | Times]
Lindberg keeps her grandson's memory alive with a collection of photographs and other mementos of him in her St. Petersburg home. "I know it's not right what I'm doing," she says of her efforts to shine a spotlight on his death, blaming the Jehovah's Witnesses. "But it's the only way I can know that my little grandson did not die in vain."
|
 |
|
[Family photo]
Dennis Lindberg, left, lived with his aunt, Dianna Mincin, center, her husband, Karl, and their daughters, Brook, right, and Hannah, front.
|
|
The ashes lie in a tiny green urn, on the coffee table of a St. Petersburg living room. The room is filled with figurines and chiming clocks, beside cards and a photograph of a smiling teenage boy.
Olga Lindberg, 66, got the ashes by agreeing not to attend the funeral of her grandson, Dennis Lindberg. Her daughter - Dennis' aunt and guardian - made the offer in what has been their last communication.
The mother-daughter relationship splintered after Nov. 8, when Dennis, 14, was diagnosed in a Seattle hospital with leukemia. His doctors had given Dennis a 70 percent chance at a full recovery, provided he accept repeated blood transfusions.
Though badly depleted from chemotherapy, Dennis refused because he was a devout Jehovah's Witness.
In a case that drew national attention, Dennis held firm. He died Nov. 28 at Children's Hospital and Regional Medical Center in Seattle, hours after a judge denied a legal attempt to force the transfusion.
His death split Olga's family and tested her faith, launching her on a mission to sway public opinion against the church. She knows that in her grief, she has become a zealot as passionate as any church member. But she presses on - for Dennis, she says, but also to purge her nightmares and her guilt.
"I know it's not right what I'm doing," she says. "But it's the only way I can know that my little grandson did not die in vain."
The daughter of a German soldier, Olga emigrated to the United States 45 years ago with an American GI.
She bore a son and a daughter, Dennis and Dianna. They were a military family, moving around the country and Germany until husband Albert, now dead, retired in St. Petersburg. Dianna attended St. Petersburg Junior College before moving to Washington state.
Dennis and his girlfriend had a son, also named Dennis. He was curious about everything, especially his German ancestors. When he saw Olga, he called her Oma instead of Grandmother and said ich liebe dich to tell her he loved her.
Dennis' family moved a lot, and during her visits Olga grew concerned about the conditions in her son's home, the lack of food and the adults who always seemed to be hanging around.
In 2003, Olga's phone rang. It was her daughter, Dianna Mincin. She'd gotten a call from a family in Idaho. Dennis' parents were drug addicts; they had left him stranded with a babysitter for four days.
"You go down to Boise, Idaho, and you get this little boy," Olga told Dianna.
- - -
Dennis flourished in his aunt's home in Mount Vernon, just outside Seattle. He loved the theater, skateboarding and the color pink. He dressed extravagantly, sometimes in suits.
In middle school, Dennis was popular and respected, befriending lonely or shy students. Or so Olga is told. Much about what she learned of Dennis came from Morgan Curry, Dennis' girlfriend in sixth and seventh grades.
He had also become increasingly active in the Jehovah's Witnesses, a faith with 30,000 members in Washington state, including Dennis' aunt. He used his personal story as a fulcrum, evangelizing to young people about the evils of drugs just as he witnessed door to door on Saturdays. He told his family that he wanted to be an electrician and help build Kingdom Halls.
Dennis was baptized in February 2007, meaning he was now ordained to do God's word. That was about the time Dennis' father legally gave up his parental rights, signing over guardianship to Dianna, 45. By then, Dennis' parents said they had stayed clean for four years but still had too many health and money problems to care for their son.
In November, Dianna called Olga in St. Petersburg to say that Dennis had leukemia and had been admitted to Children's Hospital in Seattle.
When Olga offered to fly there, Dianna said everything was under control. She phoned Dianna daily, and learned that doctors wanted Dennis to have a blood transfusion in addition to chemotherapy.
Jehovah's Witnesses believe there is no substance more sacred than blood, which is not to be "eaten" - taken into the body as in a transfusion.
"He doesn't want it," Dianna told Olga. She said she needed to respect Dennis' wishes. To Olga, respecting a 14-year-old boy's wish to die seemed outrageous.
Olga began leaving messages on Dianna's answering machine. "If you let that boy die, you die along with him," she told her.
Dennis knew from church teachings that the penalty for accepting blood was worse than death - excommunication and eventual damnation.
"If someone knowingly and unrepentingly undergoes a blood transfusion," said J.R. Brown, the Jehovah's Witnesses' national spokesman, "we would regard that person as no longer a member of our church because, obviously, he does not believe what we believe."
In St. Petersburg, Olga searched for a plan of attack. She called her son, then her lawyer. Neither could help.
"I finally realized that the Jehovah's Witnesses don't believe in blood transfusions," she says. "Then I started to worry."
- - -
Washington's Child Protective Services contended that Dennis was too young to refuse life-saving treatment, and filed a motion to compel the transfusion. The state flew in Dennis' parents, who wanted Dennis to accept the blood.
Dennis was transferred to a hospice wing. His room became a rallying point for up to 20 Jehovah's Witnesses and family members, who slept on the extra bed and on the floor or spilled into an adjacent lobby. They played a video game called Battleship with Dennis, watched DVDs and ordered pizza.
Attempts to stimulate Dennis' red blood cells with EPO, a hormone found in bone marrow, failed. Doctors gave the boy a 70 percent chance at recovery if he submitted to three years of chemotherapy and transfusions.
Olga was allowed to speak to Dennis by phone. She pleaded with him to let the doctors help him. She heard several adult voices in the background.
"Oma, it's okay," he told her. "I'm going to meet Jehovah. I'm going to have eternal life."
"You need blood now," she said, before the phone connection abruptly ended.
Whenever Olga tried to reach Dennis' room after that, a nurse told her he was sleeping.
- - -
As Dennis lay dying, the drama of his refusal played out in court. At the hearing, Teresa Vaughn, Dennis' sixth-grade teacher, heard Dianna compare Dennis' friends to Satan trying to tempt Jesus away from being crucified. Dianna says she doesn't remember saying that.
In a highly publicized ruling on Nov. 28, Superior Court Judge John Meyer denied the state's request to force a blood transfusion, calling the decision the most difficult of his career. The testimony of Dianna and others about Dennis' convictions impressed the judge, who added that he would make a different decision if the patient were his own child. Around 9 that evening, Dennis died.
Olga flew to Seattle. She went to a memorial service with 150 of Dennis' friends, former teachers and schoolmates. Even more people attended the funeral Dianna had organized. Family members on both sides had agreed to a deal offered by Dianna: If Olga and Dennis' parents would stay away from the funeral, she would share Dennis' ashes with them.
- - -
Dennis' death consumed Olga, and she never stopped to grieve. Only her favorite TV shows - 24, Lost, her soaps - provided an escape. She threw away the Jehovah's Witnesses Bible Dianna had given her.
One Friday, Olga drove a few blocks to the Kingdom Hall of Jehovah's Witnesses on 69th Street N in St. Petersburg. She burst in on a Bible study and addressed the group.
"You are all murderers," she remembers saying.
The Jehovah's Witnesses were shocked. She looked "boiling mad," remembers Frances Boyne, 76, who was there that day. The Jehovah's Witnesses were familiar with Dennis' case. They told her it had been Dennis' choice to refuse the blood.
Olga addressed a group of children, the eldest about 6. "You and you and you and you," she said, pointing to them and then to the adults in the sanctuary. "If you ever get sick, they are going to let you die."
- - -
On a Saturday morning in January, at an Albertson's store, Olga buys diet food, deodorant, smoothies. She sees an older woman by the produce and pulls her cart up near her.
"Do you have grandchildren?" she asks. "See this little boy?" She shows the woman the picture she always shows people, of Dennis playing the guitar on his hospital bed.
"The Jehovah's Witnesses killed that little boy," she says. She begins to tell the story. The woman remains still and birdlike - poised for flight. She says she has heard about that kind of thing, and moves away.
Over by frozen foods, she tries again with a white-haired woman. Angelina Fisher, 80, says that Jehovah's Witnesses would not be able to get into her gated community in South Pasadena. She soon steers the conversation to calories and yogurt.
After one more conversation with a couple who seem sympathetic, Olga swings her cart into the next aisle. Then she stops, rests her foot and elbows on the cart, puts her face in her hands and cries.
- - -
Olga carries the photo in her purse. She approaches customers at the post office. At the mall. In grocery store lines. She shows them the picture of Dennis with the guitar. Before she is finished, she will padlock Dennis' death securely to the Jehovah's Witnesses.
"When they listen," she says, "I get a little bit of relief."
Dianna is grieving, too. She remembers how firm Dennis was in the hospital - how she asked him each day if he was still comfortable with his decision. Every day he told her he had no regrets. He hoped to go to sleep and be awakened into a paradise on earth, a restored Garden of Eden where there is no leukemia. A few days before he died, Dennis asked his aunt what preparations he might make for her in the paradise, should he be resurrected first. She can't wait to see him there.
Dianna says she knows the relationship with her mother, whom she calls "an extremely emotional, fanatical woman," is likely over. "My mother has rejected me because of my faith," she said. "I have not rejected her."
As Dennis' death recedes in time, Olga has trouble sleeping. She prays nightly for forgiveness. She should have known a conflict like this could have developed out of her daughter's faith. Maybe she should have taken Dennis herself when he needed a family, instead of giving him over to Dianna. Somehow, she should have seen it coming.
Every so often, Olga is startled awake by a recurring dream. She sees Dennis sitting in a bed. He is alone, and calling to her for help.
Andrew Meacham can be reached at ameacham@sptimes.com or 813 661-2431.
[Last modified February 22, 2008, 17:06:23]
Share your thoughts on this story
Comments on this article
|
by Melanie
|
03/11/08 08:54 AM
|
|
A minor should not be allowed to make life-threatening medical decisions.
Please show your support by signing this petition.
http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/youthandbloodtransfusiondecision/index.html
|
|
by tim
|
03/10/08 09:09 AM
|
|
its unfortunate...if only Dennis could have held off till the 'rules' and doctrine changes again....it soon be a personal decsision...
|
|
by gary
|
03/09/08 11:14 AM
|
|
Im Morgan Curry's dad the Dr's gave Dennis 70% survival WITH blood. His aunt didn't believe in any parts of blood. He had several strokes and an enlarged heart from no blood 1 week after his 1st treatment, & died in 3 weeks He didn't have a choice
|
|
by kate
|
03/09/08 12:12 AM
|
|
this child was only 14 years old. He had so much more to experience in life.How can these so called christians live with their consience. the judge and all jehovas witnesses hang yourheads in shame' and pray that one day god will forgive you.
|
|
by kathy
|
03/08/08 05:37 PM
|
|
my heart goes out to this grandmother jw"s changed many bible passages god gives us children to love
|
|
by kathy
|
03/08/08 05:29 PM
|
|
my heart goes out to this lady my family has also been hurt by the jehovas witnesses
|
|
by Ken
|
03/08/08 02:09 PM
|
|
I don't suppose Jehovah's Witnesses also believe they get 77 virgins in Paradise, do they?
|
|
by Mario
|
03/04/08 03:48 PM
|
|
If you believe in something so stronly that you would die for it than so be it. Dennis, if what you did was the right thing, than God is very happy with you!
|
|
by Jlrous1@aol.com
|
03/04/08 03:07 PM
|
|
It breaks my heart that he died! His story however gives me strength! I am so proud of Dennis for standing by his beliefs based on the Bible! I am a Jehovahs Witness and I hope one day in Paradise here on earth I will get a chance to tell him.
|
|
by Shane
|
03/02/08 11:27 AM
|
|
Poor Dennis died needlessly. It's outrageous that the authorities allowed a minor being coerced by his peers into essentially allowing himself to die. Shame on the judge, shame on his Aunt, shame on the JW's. He was not an adult and deserved to live.
|
|
by Mike
|
03/02/08 03:07 AM
|
|
Please sign our petition.
http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/youthandbloodtransfusiondecision/
|
|
by Jeanette
|
02/29/08 10:10 PM
|
|
I am very Sorry Grammy Olga. JW's are nothing but a cult that helped end your grandson's life. I am fighting JW's with you. Good for you for bursting in on their cult "bible studies"...very tragic they're allowed to practice this in the United States
|
|
by Richard
|
02/28/08 06:03 PM
|
|
PT-3 a war both catholic and protestant will fight each other to the death. priests and ministers on both sides bless the military. WHAT side is God on? Maybe if other had that conviction what a better world we would have. No fighters-No wars.
|
|
by Richard
|
02/28/08 05:57 PM
|
|
PT-1 This will take more than one comment. I'm 56yrs old and was a JW untill I left at 18. The reason I left is because I am gay and that is something they can not tolerate. I attend no church at this time and haven't since I was 18. After reading
|
|
by Judy
|
02/28/08 02:25 AM
|
|
What a needless tragedy! Why can't the courts recognize that a child of any age does not have the wisdom or experience to make a life or death decision? Particularly a child that has been brainwashed by a mind-controlling cult?
|
|
by pioneerspit
|
02/27/08 11:52 PM
|
|
Gramma Olga, I'm so sorry about Dennis. I'm fighting the JWs along with you. Don't be sorry, you're the only adult in his life who ALWAYS loved him, his parents, his aunt-they all left him to die, you did not! We will defeat them in court one day!
|
|
by Disgusted
|
02/27/08 03:57 PM
|
|
JWs, go to your literature re fractions, then look google blood, and compare the two. If you combine all the fractions, it equals blood minus water. So, if Jah said you can't eat cake, would it mean you could eat flour, eggs, butter, sugar?
|
|
by Your Brother
|
02/27/08 02:00 PM
|
|
Dennis...reading this story has strengthened my Faith in Jehovah, the only true God. I have cried just as Jesus did before he resurected Lazarus. I hope to one day meet you in the paradise that Jesus spoke of at Luke 23:43. Your brother...Jamie.
|
|
by TP
|
02/27/08 01:27 PM
|
|
Jehovah's Witnesses believe that blood is the symbol of life.
Why is it that NO JW has the answer to this question...
Since when is the symbol of life more important than the reality it symbolizes?
|
|
by Dick
|
02/27/08 11:58 AM
|
|
Face it folks Who wrote the bible?? Did you ever thimk if you go up ypu go for ever Whear heaven?? ifu you drill down you eventually come out on the other side of earth whear hell?? Answere me please.dont tell me god rote bible you never seen him
|
|
by Stina
|
02/27/08 11:08 AM
|
|
He was too young to make such a choice. The Bible doesn't restrict medical treatment at all-they have a misguided interpretation that costs lives. Sad. God gives us tools in our lives and Dianna let Dennis ignore these tools. Abomination!
|
|
by Bob
|
02/27/08 11:04 AM
|
|
John S. is wrong. JW's wont accept whole blood nor blood's primary components: white blood cells, red blood cells, platelets, or plasma. Some blood derivatives are acceptable based on a person's bible trained conscience.
|
|
by Ms.Funt
|
02/27/08 10:41 AM
|
|
Like the bible says many are called but few are chosen. It's a sad thing because once your a certain age in the bibles you are responsable for your own action concerning religion.
|
|
by JQ
|
02/27/08 10:23 AM
|
|
I am not a JW, but the newspaper never has all the facts before running articles like this. The blood may or may not have saved Dennis life. There are many new blood derivatives that can be used that have the same properties as whole blood.
|
|
by Eric
|
02/27/08 09:57 AM
|
|
Give me a break. Don't base beliefs verbatim from texts written more than a thousand years before transfusions were even imagined. The bible's overall message is lasting, but its specifics are too outdated to be relevant in todays society.
|
|
by SABRINA
|
02/27/08 09:48 AM
|
|
OLGA I FEEL VERY SORRY FOR WHAT YOU HAD TO GO THROUGH IT MUST HAVE BEEN VERY HAD BUT IT WAS THEIR DECISION TO MAKE I KNOW THAT BRINGS YOU NO PEACE BUT REMEMBER THE GOOD TIMES AND MEMORIES HE IS WITH GOD NOW MAY GOD BLESS YOU
|
|
by MA
|
02/27/08 09:38 AM
|
|
Acts15:29 is speaking against heathen practices of eating sacrificed animals and their blood ... and didn't refer to transfusion of human blood which did not exist then. Although, this procedure is risky, it can also give a chance to save life.
|
|
by chris
|
02/27/08 09:01 AM
|
|
This is so sad this boy died the good Lord or who ever your higher being is didnt give us the know how to medical seince not to use it!I have a cousin that died at 16 and uncle that died at 27 over stupidty like this religion.
|
|
by DK
|
02/27/08 08:44 AM
|
|
The Bible people love to quote, was written by *man* voted by a committee to what put into the Bible.
To use the Bible to defend your beliefs saying it was written by God is ludicrous.
|
|
by Aida
|
02/27/08 07:58 AM
|
|
My mother used to be a witness growing up and into young adulthood, that all stopped when I was a 6 yr old child was diagnosed with a hole in my heart and needed open heart surgery along with several transfusions. Thank goodness she wised up.
|
|
by joe
|
02/26/08 10:18 PM
|
|
didn't Hitler say the JWs were a cult and needed to be eradicated???
|
|
by John S
|
02/26/08 07:02 PM
|
|
Witnesses wont take whole blood but they'll take all the pieces/parts that make up blood. I thought the command at Acts 15 was clear to abstain totally from blood? So hypocrital, dont you think?
|
|
by Manny
|
02/26/08 01:29 PM
|
|
Ideas have consequences. JW are a very sad bunch of people because they are not allowed to make any decisions on their own. Their leaders have complete control over them, even to what a H/W does in their bedroom. They are so brainwashed! Mercy!!
|
|
by Dan
|
02/26/08 12:37 PM
|
|
Faith is a wonderful thing when it causes good results. People are kinder and more forgiving if they believe they'll be rewarded.
Sadly, faith often decreases the quality of this life in exchange for (questionable) promises of the next. Sad Story.
|
|
by HMarie
|
02/26/08 10:55 AM
|
|
If he had been older I would say he has the right to do as he wanted, but he was to young to choose this decision...
|