St. Petersburg Times Online: World&Nation
Place an Ad Calendars Classified Forums Sports Weather

printer version

Despite helmets, head injuries rise

Experts are mystified, but some say bicyclists may be taking great risks because of helmets.

©New York Times

© St. Petersburg Times,
published July 29, 2001

Millions of parents take it as an article of faith that putting a bicycle helmet on their children, or themselves, will help keep them out of harm's way.

But new data raises questions about that assumption. The number of head injuries sustained in bicycle accidents has increased 10 percent since 1991, even as helmet use has risen sharply, according to figures compiled by the Consumer Product Safety Commission. With ridership declining over the same period, the rate of head injuries among bicyclists has increased 51 percent even as the use of bicycle helmets has become widespread.

What is going on? No one is sure, but safety experts stress that while helmets do not prevent accidents, they are extremely effective at reducing the severity of head injuries when they do occur. Almost no one suggests that riders should stop wearing helmets, which researchers have found can reduce the severity of brain injuries by as much as 88 percent.

Still, with fewer people riding bicycles, experts are mystified as to why injuries are on the rise.

"It's puzzling to me that we can't find the benefit of bike helmets here," said Ronald Medford, assistant executive director of the safety commission's hazard identification office.

Some cycling advocates say that rising numbers of aggressive drivers are at fault, while others suggest that many riders wear helmets improperly and do not know the rules of the road. Some transportation engineers say there are not enough safe places to ride.

Specialists in risk analysis argue that something else is in play. They think that the increased use of bike helmets may have had an unintended consequence: riders may feel an inflated sense of security and take more risks.

In August 1999, Philip Dunham, then 15, was riding his mountain bike in the Great Smoky Mountains National Park in North Carolina and went over a jump on a trail. As he did, his back tire kicked up, the bike flipped over and he landed on his head. The helmet he was wearing did not protect his neck; he was paralyzed from the neck down.

Two years later, Philip has regained enough movement and strength in his arms to use a manual wheelchair. He has also gained some perspective. With the helmet he felt protected enough to ride off-road on a challenging trail, in hindsight perhaps he felt too safe.

"It didn't cross my mind that this could happen," said Philip, now 17. "I definitely felt safe. I wouldn't do something like that without a helmet."

In the past nine years, 19 state legislatures have passed mandatory helmet laws. Florida requires children under age 16 to wear an approved bicycle helmet. Today, such statutes cover 49 percent of American children under 15. And even some professionals have embraced helmets. While a majority of the riders in the Tour de France have worn helmets infrequently, Lance Armstrong, the American cyclist favored to win the race today, wore a helmet through most of the race.

Altogether, about half of all riders use bike helmets today, compared with fewer than 18 percent a decade ago, the first year the safety commission examined helmet use.

During the same period, overall bicycle use has declined about 21 percent as participation in inline skating, skateboarding and other sports has increased, according to the National Sporting Goods Association, which conducts an annual survey of participation in different sports. Off-road mountain biking is often considered more risky than ordinary bicycling, but it is unlikely to account for the recent increase in bicyclists' head injuries. Participation in off-road mountain biking has declined 18 percent since 1998, the association said.

Even so, bicyclists suffered 73,750 head injuries last year, compared with 66,820 in 1991, according to the safety commission's national injury surveillance system, with the sharpest increase coming in the past three years. Children's head injuries declined until the mid 1990s, but they have risen sharply since then and now stand near their 1991 levels even with fewer children riding bikes.

The safety commission is investigating why head injuries have been increasing. Officials hope that by examining emergency room reports more closely and interviewing crash victims, they can find out if more of the injuries are relatively minor, and how many people suffered head injuries while wearing helmets. Some bicycling advocates have questioned the statistics on participation in bicycling, and the commission plans to re-examine those as well.

Dr. Richard A. Schieber, a childhood injury prevention specialist at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the leader of a national bicycle safety initiative, said public health officials were realizing that in addition to promoting helmet use, safety officials must teach good riding skills, promote good driving practices and create safer places for people to ride.

"We have moved the conversation from bicycle helmet use to bicycle safety," Schieber said. "Thank God that the public health world is understanding there is more to bicycle safety than helmets."

Promoting bicycle helmets without teaching riders about traffic laws or safe riding practices can encourage a false sense of security, according to several risk experts. Helmets may create a sort of daredevil effect, making cyclists feel so safe that they ride faster and take more chances, said Dr. Mayer Hillman, a senior fellow emeritus at the Policy Studies Institute in London.

"You would be well advised to wear a helmet provided you could persuade yourself it is of little use," Hillman said.

Even cyclists who discount the daredevil effect admit that they may ride faster on more dangerous streets when they are wearing their helmets.

On May 5, Noah Budnick, a 24-year-old New York resident, was wearing a helmet and cycling on Avenue B in Manhattan when he had to pull out from the side of the street to avoid a double-parked car and a taxicab idling behind it. As he moved to the left, the cab pulled out, striking Budnick. He broke his fall with his hands and did not hit his head on the ground, but the accident left him with a deep cut on his leg and a badly strained knee.

Although the cab was at fault for the accident, Budnick said, if he had been riding more slowly he might not have had the accident.

"I probably would have ridden more cautiously and less aggressively without the helmet," he said. "I don't know if I would ride in Manhattan at the speed I was going."

Still, many cycling advocates contend that it is not bicyclists but drivers who are more reckless. Distractions such as cell phones have made drivers less attentive, they say, and congestion is making roads more dangerous for cyclists. They also think that some drivers of sport utility vehicles and other trucks simply drive too close to cyclists.

Brendan Batson, a 16-year-old high school sophomore in central Maine, had been knocked off the road twice by drivers, so as he entered the home stretch of a 60-mile ride on May 26, he was wearing his helmet. But as he passed through Norridgewock, Maine, riding along the shoulder of a rural highway, a pickup struck him from behind. It hit Brendan with enough force to rip the helmet from his head, the straps gouging his face before tearing off. Brendan was dragged along the road, past a friend he was cycling with, then thrown to the side. He was killed instantly.

It is difficult to show statistically that drivers have become more reckless in the past decade. The percentage of fatal bicycle accidents that involved cars has declined, falling from 87 percent in 1991 to 83 percent in 1998, according to the CDC.

Thom Parks, a vice president in charge of safety for the helmetmaker Bell Sports, said safety standards could be upgraded and helmets could be designed to meet them. But that would make helmets heavier, bulkier and less comfortable.

"There are limits to what a consumer would accept," Parks said, adding that if helmets became bigger, fewer people might wear them.

Dr. James P. Kelly, a neurologist and a concussion expert at Northwestern University Medical School, said that even as helmets were currently designed, patients who were wearing them when they were injured were much better off than those who were not.

"Bicycle helmet technology is the best we have for protecting the brain," Kelly said. "The helmets serve the function of an air bag."

But the most effective way to reduce severe head injuries may be to decrease the number of accidents in the first place.

"Over the past several decades, society has come to equate safety with helmets," said Charles Komanoff, co-founder of Right of Way, an organization that promotes the rights of cyclists and pedestrians. "But wearing a helmet does not prevent crashes."

Back to World & National news
Back to Top

© 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111
Special Links
Susan Taylor Martin

From the Times wire desk
  • Despite helmets, head injuries rise
  • House Social Security bill hints at trade-offs
  • Ford leaves 2-door SUV unchanged
  • Canada's pot feeds U.S. habit
  • U.S. policy not limited to borders
  • Today's television news shows
  • Washington Journal
  • Canada report

  • From the AP
    national wire
    From the AP
    world desk