St. Petersburg Times Online: Election 2000
Place an Ad Calendars Classified Forums Sports Weather

printer version

Floridians keep right to elect judges


© St. Petersburg Times, published November 8, 2000

Floridians voted overwhelmingly to continue electing the state's more than 750 trial judges, soundly defeating a movement by the state's legal community to have the governor appoint them.

In judicial circuits and counties across the state, voters favored retaining their right to select the judges who run some of Florida's busiest courts and have the most contact with ordinary citizens.

The Tampa Bay area followed that trend. Voters in the counties of Pinellas, Hillsborough, Pasco, Hernando and Citrus will keep electing county and circuit judges every six years.

"People like to elect their public officials," Hillsborough Chief Judge Dennis Alvarez said Tuesday night. "It's the American way."

The choice to appoint or elect judges was before voters because of a constitutional amendment Floridians approved in 1998.

If the change had been approved, the governor would fill openings on the bench based on recommendations from local nominating commissions, and voters would have decided whether to retain sitting judges -- much as they do for appellate and Supreme Court judges.

But those who wanted to hold onto the current system said they didn't want voters to lose more rights by switching to the "merit selection system," which would have given more power to a small group of politically connected people.

"The system works," said Oscar Marrero, president of the Cuban-American Bar Association. "This is a victory for the entire community and for the administration of justice."

Although the appointment process is credited with making the judiciary more diverse, several groups representing minority attorneys wanted to retain elections.

The National Bar Association, the Hispanic Bar Association, the Cuban-American Bar Association and the Florida Association for Women Lawyers supported the current system -- much to the dismay of the Florida Bar, which counts every lawyer as a member.

Tuesday's election was a blow to legal heavyweights such as the American Bar Association and the Florida Bar, which spent about $70,000 lobbying for the change around the state.

"We're very disappointed," said Terry Russell, president-elect of the Florida Bar. "I think we're stuck with a lousy way of picking judges. It's too bad."

Those who supported appointments say judicial elections are flawed and ineffective. Besides, contested judicial races are extremely rare, and if no one runs against a judge, his or her name never appears on the ballot.

In lobbying for the change, the Bar said candidates are in races where judicial ethics prevent them from talking about issues, which leaves voters to choose a winner on name recognition alone and, perhaps, on promises they might not be able to fulfill. Candidates also are put in the position of accepting campaign donations from lawyers and special interest groups that might appear before them.

Russell blamed the defeat on confusing ballot language, saying voters may have voted against the change because they didn't understand the questions. "We did the best we could," he said.

Under the current system, the governor makes appointments only if vacancies occur between elections because of illnesses, resignations or retirements.

That happens so frequently that more than half the state's 753 trial judges owe their seats to governors.

"Really what we have now is the best of both worlds," Pinellas-Pasco Chief Judge Susan Schaeffer said. "I don't fault the voters for keeping it."

Results for judicial selection elections

A "yes" vote favors changing to a system of appointment and merit retention. A "no" vote indicates a preference for the current system of election and merit retention. Results are as of 11:00 p.m.

(Appointment of circuit judges, YES/NO

Fifth Judicial Circuit (Hernando and Citrus counties) -- 80,817(33.50%) /160,298(66.50%)

Sixth Judicial Circuit (Pinellas and Pasco counties) -123,596 (38.30%)/ 199,402 (61.70%) Thirteenth Judicial Circuit (Hillsborough County) -- 32,169 (30.60%)/ 72,837 (69.40%)

* * *

(Appointment of county judges, YES/NO

Citrus County -15,900 (29.30%) /38,278 (70.70%)

Hernando County -19,199 (31.90%) /41,075 (68.10%)

Hillsborough County -28,861 (28.00%) /74,360 (72.00%)

Pasco County -44,279 (34.40%) /84,274 (65.60%)

Pinellas County -67,379 (34.60%) / 127,342 (65.40%)

Back to Election 2000
Back to Top

© 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111
Special Links
Tim Nickens
The Presidential race
Florida races
Pinellas races
Hillsborough races
Pasco races
Hernando races
Citrus races

From the Times election desk

  • Recount: Presidency hangs on Florida duel
  • Hour by hour, outcome gets more uncertain
  • State by state
  • Republicans make gains in skirmish for 83 seats
  • Uneasy mood in Austin flips as votes do
  • Voters swayed by economy, health care, education, Social Security
  • Too close to call in Florida but TV did -- regretfully
  • Presidential campaign lures people to polls
  • Fight for Congress: no clear-cut winner
  • Election 2000 in brief

  • State
  • Nelson takes Senate seat
  • Republican Crist well on path to victory
  • Incumbent Crow slightly ahead
  • Race turns into nail-biter
  • Byrd dominating in bid for third term
  • Farkas soundly beats Fischer
  • Foster breaks ahead, takes lead over Baldwin
  • Wallace jumps to early lead over his challenger
  • Henriquez holds strong lead
  • Cowin gains ground in home county
  • Incumbent strides ahead of newcomer
  • Justice leading Kersteen by a comfortable margin
  • Murman headed for second term
  • Newcomer battle ends with Republican Berfield as victor
  • Waters blocks Brennan challenge
  • Miller's hopes look to be affirmed
  • Miller overpowers former Democrat
  • Floridians keep right to elect judges
  • Crist has slight lead on Castor
  • Thurman keeps District 5 seat
  • Bilirakis has big lead in District 9
  • C.W. Bill Young winning handily
  • Bullet train heading for success
  • Davis wins third term
  • Putnam takes early lead
  • Incumbent Russell's win thinner than predicted
  • GOP Rep. Miller is likely victor
  • Floridians keep right to elect judges
  • Gallagher coasts to victory and his old job
  • Littlefield again defeats McLaughlin
  • Fasano, Fiorentino winning return trip
  • Election roundup
  • Briefly

  • Pinellas
  • Pinellas commission now full
  • One race won by landslide, another by a single vote
  • Lealman heads toward fire tax
  • Bobel, Dedman win approval
  • All changes to charter pass voters' muster
  • Peluso, Henry lead pack of 5 candidates

  • Hillsborough
  • Voters favor most amendments
  • Democrats bustle to get the vote out
  • Iorio builds her solid lead on record
  • Holt closing in on a third term
  • Term limits prevailing
  • Ober poised in attorney race
  • Republicans may reign in commission
  • Ake appears on his way to keep tenure unbroken
  • Results mixed on city amendments
  • Incumbent trails in four-way race
  • Two incumbents, Miller leading

  • Pasco
  • Altman holds slim lead
  • Challenger upsets incumbent Cannon
  • Second run is the charm for Schrader
  • Johnson captures Meadow Pointe post

  • Hernando
  • Bernardini bests longtime adversary
  • Sikes will succeed her sister upon retirement
  • Experienced teacher wins out over mom
  • Williams captures historic win
  • Early tally: Andrews first, Martin second, Hollander third
  • Democrats take over the board
  • Big ticket polls' big draw

  • Citrus
  • Activist Warren sails past Cooper
  • Council incumbents out; new mayor in
  • Schultz wins, will serve a final term ending in 2004
  • Hickey wins Citrus superintendent race
  • Bush is easy winner in the schoolhouse
  • Eager voters met with long lines
  • Candidate bounces out of hospital to ply voters

  • From the AP
    national wire
  • Bush Pledges Iraq Arms Hunt Will Continue
  • 'Partial Birth' Abortion Ban Passes House