St. Petersburg Times Online: Election 2000
Place an Ad Calendars Classified Forums Sports Weather

Hour by hour, the outcome gets more uncertain

Click here

© St. Petersburg Times, published November 8, 2000

On an extraordinary night in an extraordinary election, Florida kept the election for president hanging in the balance.

For a few short minutes, it appeared clear that Republican George W. Bush defeated Vice President Al Gore in Florida and won the presidency.

About 2:20 a.m., Republican George W. Bush was declared the winner of the state's 25 electoral votes, and the presidency, by the television networks.

In Austin, Texas, the crowds started cheering. Gore telephoned Bush to concede, and the television networks announced Gore would soon be arriving to speak to his supporters in Nashville.

[AP Photo]
Republican presidential candidate George W. Bush watches election returns Tuesday in Austin, Texas.
But Bush's advantage over Gore in Florida kept shrinking. It shrank so far that it appears certain to have triggered an automatic recount required by state law in elections where the margin is less than 1/2 of 1 percent.

By 3 a.m., Bush's lead in Florida had been cut to several hundred votes. The Florida Secretary of State's Office reported that 99.7 percent of the precincts had been counted, and the difference was less than one-tenth of 1 percent.

At 3:11 a.m. the Associated Press alerted its members that it "believes the uncounted votes in Broward and Palm Beach counties could allow a change of the lead in the Florida vote. We are watching the resolution of the actual vote count to assure if there is a change in the Florida results, which could yet have an impact on the outcome of the presidential election."

At 3:27 a.m., CBS' Dan Rather announced there was a difference of just 629 votes between Bush and Gore in Florida.

A few minutes later, Attorney General Bob Butterworth, Gore's state chairman, told the St. Petersburg Times that he believed the difference was less than 500 votes and that several thousand ballots were left to count, including ballots in heavily Democratic Broward County. In the meantime, television reports said elections officials were preparing to recount five precincts in Miami-Dade County.

By 3:30 a.m., the crowd of Gore supporters were chanting, "Recount!"

By 3:45 a.m., Gore called Bush back and retracted his concession.

Butterworth, closely monitoring the Florida results, said neither Gore nor Bush should be making any speeches.

"I don't think Gore should make any concession," he said. "I don't think George W. should make a speech right now because he might not be winning."

In Tallahassee, Clay Roberts, the head of the state Division of Elections, said that all Miami-Dade County ballots had been counted. "We're waiting for some ballots from Broward," Roberts said.

At 3:56 a.m. the Associated Press reported that Bush communications director Karen Hughes said Gore had called Bush back.

"He called an hour ago to concede," Hughes said. "He just called us back to retract that concession."

Shortly before 4 a.m., television networks moved Florida back into the undecided column.

Butterworth predicted it would take until mid afternoon to work through the recount. In Austin, Florida Gov. Jeb Bush was on the computer himself and reviewing the Web site for the Florida of Division of Elections.

About 4:08 a.m., Gore campaign manager William Daley addressed the crowd standing in the rain in Nashville.

"As everyone knows in America," Daley told the crowd, "this race has come down to the state of Florida. Without being certain of the results in Florida, we cannot be certain of the results in this national election."

Daley said Gore and running mate Joseph Lieberman would concede if the results indicated Bush had won. But he said, "Until the results in Florida become official, our campaign continues. . . . I hope to see you back here very soon."

The crowd roared and went home.

At 4:08 a.m. in Austin, Bush campaign chairman Don Evans addressed the crowd.

"When it is all said and done,"Evans said, "we will prevail."

The early morning drama was only the latest flip-flop involving the contest in Florida.

By 7:50 p.m., less than one hour after the polls closed in Florida, MSNBC, five television networks (ABC, CBS, CNN, Fox and NBC) and the Associated Press news service called Florida for Gore based on exit polls by Voter News Service, based mainly on exit poll interviews.

"That was too early," Butterworth said later.

The Bush entourage, including the candidate, his wife and daughters, his parents, and Jeb, were having dinner at the Shoreline Grill in downtown Austin, and had announced plans to watch election returns together at the adjoining Four Seasons Hotel. But at dinner the family got the bad news about Florida.

Afterward Bush, his wife and parents returned to the Governor's Mansion, leaving the rest of the family, including Jeb, behind.

About 9:30 p.m.: Bush told reporters he still expected to prevail in Florida: "I don't believe some of these states that they (news organizations) called, like Florida."

At 9:55 p.m., Sid Bedingfield, the executive vice president of CNN/US, makes the decision -- amid much shouting in the network's Atlanta control room -- to move Florida back into the too-close-to-call category, some two hours after the networks had handed it to Gore. Other networks and media outlets followed soon after.

"Some suspect data was discovered," Rather said.

A crowd of thousands of Bush supporters, watching on a large-screen television set up at a street party in front of the Texas Capitol, roared in delight as Florida was declared still in play.

It turned out it would remain in play longer than anyone imagined.

-- Staff writers Bill Adair and Mary Jacoby contributed to this report.

Back to Election 2000

Back to Top

© 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111
Special Links
Tim Nickens
The Presidential race
Florida races
Pinellas races
Hillsborough races
Pasco races
Hernando races
Citrus races

From the Times election desk

  • Recount: Presidency hangs on Florida duel
  • Hour by hour, outcome gets more uncertain
  • State by state
  • Republicans make gains in skirmish for 83 seats
  • Uneasy mood in Austin flips as votes do
  • Voters swayed by economy, health care, education, Social Security
  • Too close to call in Florida but TV did -- regretfully
  • Presidential campaign lures people to polls
  • Fight for Congress: no clear-cut winner
  • Election 2000 in brief

  • State
  • Nelson takes Senate seat
  • Republican Crist well on path to victory
  • Incumbent Crow slightly ahead
  • Race turns into nail-biter
  • Byrd dominating in bid for third term
  • Farkas soundly beats Fischer
  • Foster breaks ahead, takes lead over Baldwin
  • Wallace jumps to early lead over his challenger
  • Henriquez holds strong lead
  • Cowin gains ground in home county
  • Incumbent strides ahead of newcomer
  • Justice leading Kersteen by a comfortable margin
  • Murman headed for second term
  • Newcomer battle ends with Republican Berfield as victor
  • Waters blocks Brennan challenge
  • Miller's hopes look to be affirmed
  • Miller overpowers former Democrat
  • Floridians keep right to elect judges
  • Crist has slight lead on Castor
  • Thurman keeps District 5 seat
  • Bilirakis has big lead in District 9
  • C.W. Bill Young winning handily
  • Bullet train heading for success
  • Davis wins third term
  • Putnam takes early lead
  • Incumbent Russell's win thinner than predicted
  • GOP Rep. Miller is likely victor
  • Floridians keep right to elect judges
  • Gallagher coasts to victory and his old job
  • Littlefield again defeats McLaughlin
  • Fasano, Fiorentino winning return trip
  • Election roundup
  • Briefly

  • Pinellas
  • Pinellas commission now full
  • One race won by landslide, another by a single vote
  • Lealman heads toward fire tax
  • Bobel, Dedman win approval
  • All changes to charter pass voters' muster
  • Peluso, Henry lead pack of 5 candidates

  • Hillsborough
  • Voters favor most amendments
  • Democrats bustle to get the vote out
  • Iorio builds her solid lead on record
  • Holt closing in on a third term
  • Term limits prevailing
  • Ober poised in attorney race
  • Republicans may reign in commission
  • Ake appears on his way to keep tenure unbroken
  • Results mixed on city amendments
  • Incumbent trails in four-way race
  • Two incumbents, Miller leading

  • Pasco
  • Altman holds slim lead
  • Challenger upsets incumbent Cannon
  • Second run is the charm for Schrader
  • Johnson captures Meadow Pointe post

  • Hernando
  • Bernardini bests longtime adversary
  • Sikes will succeed her sister upon retirement
  • Experienced teacher wins out over mom
  • Williams captures historic win
  • Early tally: Andrews first, Martin second, Hollander third
  • Democrats take over the board
  • Big ticket polls' big draw

  • Citrus
  • Activist Warren sails past Cooper
  • Council incumbents out; new mayor in
  • Schultz wins, will serve a final term ending in 2004
  • Hickey wins Citrus superintendent race
  • Bush is easy winner in the schoolhouse
  • Eager voters met with long lines
  • Candidate bounces out of hospital to ply voters

  • From the AP
    national wire
  • Bush Pledges Iraq Arms Hunt Will Continue
  • 'Partial Birth' Abortion Ban Passes House