St. Petersburg Times Online: News of Florida
Place an Ad Calendars Classified Forums Sports Weather
  • Florida tightening rules for licenses
  • State seeks fines for post-attack gas price gouging
  • 'Endeavour' blasts off amid tight security
  • Bush's tax cut wins delay despite several GOP nays
  • Capitol recycling buried in inaction
  • Court voids notable domestic abuse award
  • State will remove plant's acidic water
  • Audit blasts lapses at civil rights agency

  • From the state wire

  • Hurricane Jeanne appears on track to hit Florida's east coast
  • Rumor mill working overtime after Florida hurricanes
  • Developments associated with Hurricanes Ivan and Jeanne
  • Four killed in Panhandle plane crash were on Ivan charity mission
  • Hurricane Frances caused estimated $4.4 billion in insured damage
  • Disabled want more handicapped-accessible voting machines
  • USF forces administrators to resign over test score changes
  • Man's death at Universal Studios ruled accidental
  • State child welfare workers in Miami fail to do background checks
  • Hurricane Jeanne heads toward southeast U.S. coast
  • Hurricane Jeanne spurs more anxiety for storm-weary Floridians
  • Mistrial declared in case where teen was target of racial "joke"
  • Panhandle utility wants sewer plant moved to higher ground
  • State employee arrested on theft, bribery charges
  • Homestead house fire kills four children, one adult
  • Pierson leader tries to cut off relief to local fern cutters
  • Florida's high court rules Terri's law unconstitutional
  • Jacksonville students punished for putting stripper pole in dorm
  • FEMA handling nearly 600,000 applications for help
  • Man who killed wife, niece, self also killed mother in 1971
  • Producer sues city over lead ball fired by Miami police
  • Tourism suffers across Florida after pummeling by hurricanes
  • Key dates in the life of Terri Schiavo
  • An excerpt from the unanimous ruling in the Schiavo case
  • Four confirmed dead after small plane crash in Panhandle
  • Correction: Disney-Cruise Line story

    printer version

    Court voids notable domestic abuse award

    An appellate court overturns the $1.7-million verdict against a businessman accused of battering his former girlfriend.

    © St. Petersburg Times,
    published December 6, 2001

    An appeals court Wednesday overturned a $1.7-million jury verdict against a former Treasure Island city commissioner accused by a former girlfriend of beating her.

    The judgment against businessman George W. Garbutt was hailed in 1997 by advocates for battered women as one of the largest ever levied in Florida civil courts against someone accused of domestic violence.

    But the 2nd District Court of Appeal ruled that an attorney for Rosemary Lafarnara, the former girlfriend, made improper comments during his closing argument to a jury four years ago. So the court ordered a new trial.

    The appeals court did not describe the improper argument. But Garbutt's attorneys had previously accused Lafarnara's attorney, Robert Merkle, of impugning their integrity and improperly accusing them of lying to jurors, among other things.

    Garbutt, 74, and his attorneys did not return calls for comment. Merkle said he planned a swift appeal of the decision.

    "I think the jurors in this case will be as surprised, shocked and troubled by this ruling as I am," Merkle said. "My closing was not just appropriate, it was based on the evidence."

    Garbutt served nearly 15 years on the Treasure Island City Commission, leaving in 1987. He met Lafarnara at the end of 1985 at an Arthur Murray Dance Studio where she was an instructor. The couple moved in together in March 1987 and lived together for about two years, according to court testimony.

    Lafarnara, 65, testified that Garbutt beat her repeatedly. She said she was knocked unconscious twice and suffered two concussions. Garbutt, who was not charged criminally, denied the allegations.

    After the couple broke up, Garbutt stalked Lafarnara, often making threatening phone calls laced with "demonic laughter," Merkle said at trial. The phone calls and stalking continued throughout the trial, according to testimony, and Garbutt even called his former girlfriend the day after the jury returned its verdict, Merkle has previously said.

    Lafarnara sued Garbutt for assault, battery, defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress. The jury award included both punitive and compensatory damages.

    The appeals court earlier had refused to grant a new trial because Garbutt's lawyers did not, at trial, object to improper statements during the closing argument.

    But the new decision came after the Florida Supreme Court clarified that an attorney need not object immediately when the statement is made, so long as an objection is made soon afterward.

    Back to State news
    Back to Top

    © 2006 • All Rights Reserved • Tampa Bay Times
    490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111
    Special Links
    Lucy Morgan

    From the Times state desk